Volkswagen Amarok vs Volkswagen Caddy

In-depth comparison in South Africa covering price, performance, fuel efficiency, safety, practicality and long-term ownership costs.

Volkswagen Amarok

3.0 V6 TDI Double Cab Aventura 4Motion AT Diesel Automatic

Switch Variant

Change Car A

ZAR 1,252,200 ex-showroom

⚡ 125 kW (168 hp)

🔧 400 Nm

⛽ 12.8 km/l

Volkswagen Caddy

1.6 Panel Van MT Petrol Manual

Change Car B

ZAR 427,200 ex-showroom

⚡ 75 kW (101 hp)

🔧 155 Nm

⛽ 13.5 km/l

＋

Add a 3rd car to compare

Choose a car

Quick Winners

⚡ Performance Amarok

⛽ Mileage Caddy

🔑 Ownership Tie

Overall Comparison Score

🏆 Winner

Amarok

/ 100

pts

Caddy

/ 100

Very close match. Final decision depends on buyer preference.

Executive Summary

Amarok has a slight advantage, but Caddy remains highly competitive.

Key Differences At A Glance

Performance Amarok +7 pts

Efficiency Caddy +1 pts

Safety Amarok +6 pts

Practicality Caddy +4 pts

Ownership Equal

Category Score Breakdown

🏆 Overall Winner

Amarok

Performance 13/20

Efficiency 7/20

Safety 18/20

Practicality 7/20

Ownership 12/20

Caddy

Performance 6/20

Efficiency 8/20

Safety 12/20

Practicality 11/20

Ownership 12/20

Pros & Cons

🏆 Overall Winner

Amarok

Pros

More powerful engine output
Stronger safety package

Cons

Lower fuel efficiency
Less practical in daily usage

Best For: Highway Driving

Caddy

Pros

Better fuel efficiency
More practical for daily use

Cons

Less powerful engine setup
Less comprehensive safety features

Best For: Fuel Efficiency Family Usage

Who Should Buy Which?

Amarok

Drivers who prioritise strong highway performance and overtaking power
Families prioritising stronger safety equipment

Caddy

Buyers looking for better fuel efficiency
Large families needing more practicality and usability

Full Specification Comparison

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
Ground Clearance	192	170
Wheelbase	3097	2755
Length	5254	4499
Width	1944	1794
Height	1834	1832
Kerb Weight	2095	1395
Gross Vehicle Weight	3150	2200
Seating Capacity	5	2
Boot Space	0	351
Towing Capacity	3500	1000
Front Track Width	-	1522
Rear Track Width	-	1497
Turning Radius	-	5.1

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
Engine	2.0L TDI Turbo Diesel	1.6L MPI Petrol
Engine Type	Inline 4 Turbocharged Intercooled	Inline 4-cylinder MPI
Displacement	1968	1598
Cylinders	4	3
Valves per Cylinder	4	4
Power	125	75
Torque	400	155
Fuel System	Common Rail Direct Injection	Direct Injection
Turbocharger	Twin Turbo	Not Available
Top Speed	180	160
0-100 km/h	10.5	14.5
Power @ RPM	-	3500 rpm
Torque @ RPM	-	3800 rpm
Compression Ratio	-	10.5:1
Engine Position	-	Front Transverse

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
Transmission	8-Speed Automatic	5-speed Manual
Drive Type	4Motion AWD	FWD
Drivetrain Layout	Selectable 4WD	Front Wheel Drive
LSD Available	Electronic Rear Differential Lock	Not Available
Transfer Case	High and Low Range	Not Applicable
Paddle Shifters	-	Not Available
Differential Lock	-	Not Applicable

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
Traction Control	Standard	Standard
Electronic Stability Control	Standard	Standard
Airbags	6	4
ABS	Standard	Standard
Brake Assist	Standard	Standard
Hill Descent Control	Standard	Not Available
ISOFIX Mounts	Standard	Standard
Child Safety Lock	Standard	Standard
Engine Immobiliser	Standard	Standard
Alarm System	Standard	Standard
Tyre Pressure Monitor	Standard	Standard
Hill Start Assist	-	Standard
Central Locking	-	Standard
Side Impact Beams	-	Standard

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
Claimed Mileage	12.8	13.5
City Mileage	9	11
Highway Mileage	13	16
Fuel Tank Capacity	80	55
Emission Standard	Euro 5	Euro 6
AdBlue Tank Capacity	-	Not Applicable
Auto Start Stop	-	Standard

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
CO2 Emissions	225	182
Start Stop System	Yes	Standard
Hybrid System Type	None	Not Applicable
Noise Level	-	67

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
Cruise Control	Standard	Not Available
Adaptive Cruise Control	Not Available	Not Available
Lane Keep Assist	Not Available	Not Available
Blind Spot Monitoring	Not Available	Not Available
Rear Cross Traffic Alert	Not Available	Not Available
Parking Sensors	Front and Rear	Not Available
Rear View Camera	Standard	Not Available
360 Degree Camera	Not Available	Not Available
Autonomous Emergency Braking	Not Available	Not Available
Lane Departure Warning	-	Not Available
Driver Fatigue Alert	-	Not Available
Traffic Sign Recognition	-	Not Available

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
Seat Material	Fabric	Fabric
Seat Adjustment	Manual	Manual
Heated Seats	Not Available	Not Available
Ventilated Seats	Not Available	Not Available
Steering Type	Power Assisted	Electric Power Assisted
Steering Adjustment	Tilt and Telescopic	Height Adjustable
Ambient Lighting	Not Available	Not Available
Folding Rear Seats	-	60/40 Split
Front Armrest	-	Not Available
Rear Armrest	-	Not Available

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
Climate Control	Automatic	Not Available
Power Windows	Front and Rear	All Doors
Keyless Entry	Remote Key	Standard
Push Button Start	Not Available	Not Available
Wireless Charging	Not Available	Not Available
Sunroof	Not Available	Not Available
Electric Tailgate	Not Available	Not Available
Automatic Headlamps	-	Not Available
Rain Sensing Wipers	-	Not Available
Auto Dimming Mirror	-	Not Available

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
Infotainment Screen	8-inch Touchscreen	Basic Radio
Apple CarPlay	Standard	Not Available
Android Auto	Standard	Not Available
Bluetooth Connectivity	Standard	Standard
USB Ports	Front and Rear	1
Number of Speakers	6	4
Navigation System	Optional	Not Available
Digital Instrument Cluster	Not Available	Not Available
Wireless Apple CarPlay	-	Not Available

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
LED Headlamps	Halogen Projector	Halogen
Daytime Running Lamps	LED	LED
Fog Lamps	Front	Not Available
Roof Rails	Not Available	Not Available
Alloy Wheel Design	17-inch Alloy	Steel Wheels
Chrome Exterior Finish	-	Not Available
Body Cladding	-	Not Available
Rear Spoiler	-	Not Available

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
Approach Angle	29	-
Departure Angle	24	-
Wading Depth	500	-
Terrain Modes	Offroad Mode	-
Locking Differential	Electronic Rear Lock	-

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
Tyre Size	255/65 R17	195/65 R15
Wheel Type	Alloy	Steel
Front Brake Type	Ventilated Disc	Ventilated Disc
Rear Brake Type	Drum	Drum
Spare Wheel Type	-	Full Size Steel

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
Front Suspension	Double Wishbone	MacPherson Strut
Rear Suspension	Leaf Spring	Torsion Beam
Chassis Type	Ladder Frame	Monocoque
Power Steering	-	Electric
Steering Column	-	Height Adjustable

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
Service Interval	15000 km / 12 months	15,000 km or 1 Year
Approx Service Cost	Moderate	Approx R4,200
Battery Warranty	24 Months	Not Applicable
Maintenance Plan	-	Optional

Specification	Amarok	Caddy
Warranty Years	3	3
Warranty Kilometers	120000	100000
Roadside Assistance	3 Years	3 Years
Anti-Corrosion Warranty	-	6 Years

Final Verdict

🏆 Volkswagen Amarok wins with 57 pts vs 49 pts for Caddy

In structured scoring, Amarok emerges as the stronger overall package. However, Caddy may appeal to buyers prioritising different factors. Ultimately, the right choice depends on your driving priorities in South Africa.

People Also Compare

Popular comparisons among buyers considering similar options.

Frequently Asked Questions

Based on structured category scoring, Amarok performs better overall in South Africa. However, final choice depends on driving priorities.

Amarok scores 7 while Caddy scores 8 in efficiency. Real-world mileage may vary based on driving conditions.

In safety scoring, Amarok scores 18 and Caddy scores 12. Both offer competitive safety packages in this segment.

Amarok scores 12 versus Caddy scoring 12. Warranty coverage and ownership value influence this result.

Practicality scoring gives Amarok 7 and Caddy 11, reflecting cabin space and usability.

Performance category shows Amarok scoring 13 compared to Caddy scoring 6, indicating stronger overtaking capability.

While resale depends on market demand, ownership and brand positioning suggest Amarok may hold stronger long-term value.

Off-road suitability depends on drivetrain and ground clearance. Refer to the full specification comparison for detailed technical differences.

Efficiency and ownership categories influence running costs. Amarok performs slightly stronger overall in structured scoring.

Value depends on feature set, performance and ownership coverage. Structured comparison gives Amarok the overall advantage.

Detailed Comparison Analysis

The comparison between Amarok and Caddy in South Africa evaluates performance, efficiency, safety, practicality and long-term ownership value.

Performance: Amarok scores 13 vs 6.

Efficiency: Amarok scores 7 vs 8.

Safety: Amarok scores 18 vs 12.

Practicality: Amarok scores 7 vs 11.

Ownership: Amarok scores 12 vs 12.

Final structured scoring gives Amarok the advantage in this comparison.

Volkswagen Amarok vs Volkswagen Caddy

Volkswagen Amarok

Volkswagen Caddy

Quick Winners

Overall Comparison Score

Amarok

Caddy

Executive Summary

Key Differences At A Glance

Category Score Breakdown

Amarok

Caddy

Pros & Cons

Amarok

Caddy

Who Should Buy Which?

Amarok

Caddy

Full Specification Comparison

Final Verdict

Related Comparisons

People Also Compare

Frequently Asked Questions

Detailed Comparison Analysis