KIA Carnival vs Toyota GR86

A proper head-to-head in South Africa — compare price, performance, fuel economy or electric range, safety and the details that shape long-term ownership.

KIA Carnival in South Africa

KIA Carnival

2.2 CRDi SXL AT Diesel 8-Speed Automatic Current
ZAR 1,299,995 ex-showroom
⚡ 148 kW 🔧 440 Nm ⛽ 13.9 km/l
VS
Toyota GR86 in South Africa

Toyota GR86

2.4 Automatic Petrol 6-Speed Automatic Current
ZAR 799,900 ex-showroom
⚡ 173 kW 🔧 250 Nm ⛽ 10.9 km/l
+ Add a 3rd car

Decision summary

KIA Carnival vs Toyota GR86: the short answer

Carnival has a modest catalogue-index lead, while GR86 remains close.

GR86 starts ZAR 300,095 cheaper Carnival from ZAR 1,049,995 · GR86 from ZAR 749,900

Five key differences

Exact selected derivatives
Specification Carnival GR86
Maximum Power Carnival148 kW @ 3800 rpm GR86173 kW @ 7000 rpm
Maximum Torque Carnival440 Nm @ 1750 rpm GR86250 Nm @ 3700 rpm
Engine Size Carnival2151 cc GR862387 cc
Combined Fuel Economy Carnival13.9 km/l GR8610.9 km/l
Ground Clearance Carnival175 mm GR86130 mm

Strongest published figure in that row; no road-test winner is implied.

Independent editorial assessment

Hagalu editorial ratings

When a variant is selected, its rating out of five applies only to that exact derivative; a model-range review is not inherited. Editorial ratings are separate from the Specification Evidence Index out of 100 and are not customer ratings.

KIA Carnival

2.2 CRDi SXL AT

Hagalu editorial rating Not yet rated

No complete editorial rating is published for this exact variant. This is not a zero score.

How Hagalu rates cars

Toyota GR86

2.4 Automatic

Hagalu editorial rating Not yet rated

No complete editorial rating is published for this exact variant. This is not a zero score.

How Hagalu rates cars

Not yet rated means a complete review is not published; it does not mean the vehicle scored zero. Read the rating methodology.

What Each Car Gets Right (and Wrong)

Specification evidence leader

Carnival

Strengths
  • Better fuel efficiency
  • Stronger listed safety equipment
  • Stronger published practicality figures
  • Stronger published ownership cover
Weak Spots
  • No obvious weak spots to flag.
Best suited to: Published Efficiency Published Practicality

GR86

Strengths
  • Nothing stands out clearly here.
Weak Spots
  • Lower fuel efficiency
  • Fewer listed safety features
  • Lower published practicality figures
  • Lower published ownership cover
Best suited to: General Use

Which One's Right for You?

Carnival

  • Buyers prioritising the lower published fuel or energy use
  • Buyers prioritising the more complete listed safety equipment
  • Buyers prioritising the stronger published space and capacity figures
  • Buyers prioritising the stronger published warranty or service cover

GR86

  • Buyers who prefer this derivative's confirmed specification mix

Full Specs, Side by Side

Spec Carnival GR86
Intercooler Yes -
Rev Matching No -
Performance Data Logger No -
Fuel Consumption Combined 7.2 9.2
Engine Start Stop Yes Standard
Engine Start Stop Button Yes Standard
Engine Start Button Illumination Yes Standard
Engine Check Warning Yes -
Drag Coefficient 0.38 -
Roof Load 100 kg -
Boot Space Seats Folded 2785 l 237 l
Stabilizer Bar Yes -
Steering Response Normal -
Skid Plates No Not Available
Side Steps No -
Spare Wheel Temporary Spare Space Saver
Tyre Repair Kit No -
Seatbelt Pre Tensioner Yes -
Hill Start Assist Yes Standard
Speed Limiter Yes -
Speed Alert System Yes -
Impact Sensing Door Unlock Yes -
Surround View Monitor Yes Not Available
Adaptive Dampers No -
Wireless Charging Yes Not Available
Voice Command Yes Standard
Voice Command Support Yes Standard
Digital Speedometer Yes 7-inch Digital
Driver Display Digital Cluster -
Heads Up Display Yes -
Tachometer Yes -
Trip Computer Yes -
Multi Function Steering Yes -
Steering Mounted Controls Yes -
Air Conditioning Yes Manual AC
AC Type Yes Manual AC
Climate Control Yes Manual AC
Climate Zones 3 Manual AC
Rear Air Conditioning Yes -
Glovebox Cooling No -
Seat Type Leather Seats Sport Fabric/Suede
Driver Seat Height Adjustment Yes -
Rear Seat Split Yes 50/50 Split
Headrest Adjustable Yes -
Front Armrest Centre Armrest Standard
Vanity Mirror Yes -
12V Accessory Socket Yes -
Front Power Outlet Yes -
Rear Reading Lamps Yes -
Keyless Entry Yes Standard
Push Button Start Yes Standard
Push Button Start Yes Standard
Remote Engine Start No -
Remote Start No -
Remote Central Locking Yes Standard
Door Ajar Warning Yes -
Fuel Lid Opener Remote -
Boot Opener Remote -
Power Windows Yes All Doors
Power Mirrors Yes All Doors
Heated Mirrors Yes -
Electric Folding Mirrors Yes All Doors
Electric Mirror Folding Yes -
Remote Side Mirror Yes -
Auto Dimming Irvm Yes Standard
Auto Dimming Mirror Yes Standard
Rain Sensing Wipers Yes Standard
Rear Window Defroster Yes -
Rear Defogger Yes -
Follow Me Home Headlamps Yes -
Tail Lamps Yes -
Automatic Headlamps Yes Standard
Headlamp Height Adjust Yes -
Headlamp Washer No -
Sunroof No Not Available
Panoramic Roof No Not Available
Roof Antenna Yes -
Rear Wing No Rear Spoiler
Aero Kit No -
Chrome Grille Yes -
Chrome Exterior Highlights Yes -
Ride Mode Selection Yes -
Electric Tailgate Yes Not Available
Powered Tailgate Yes Not Available
Power Sliding Doors No -
Engine Warranty 7 Years / 150,000 km Not Applicable
Service Reminder Yes -
Trim Level top top
Variant Role Flagship / premium derivative Core range derivative
Vehicle To Load Not Available Not Available
Accelerator 0 100 10.0 sec 6.9 sec
Common Rail Injection Common Rail Direct Injection Direct + Port Injection
Diff Lock No Not Applicable
Difflock No Not Applicable
Vdc Yes Standard with Track Mode
TPMS Yes Standard
Sonar Yes Rear
Automatic High Beam Yes -
Steering Column Adjustment Tilt and Telescopic Tilt and Telescopic
Tilt Steering Tilt and Telescopic Tilt and Telescopic
Telescopic Steering Tilt and Telescopic Tilt and Telescopic
Bottle Holders 8 -
Glove Box Yes -
Manual Aircon Yes Manual AC
Intelligent Keyless Entry Yes Standard
Passive Entry Start Yes Standard
Wireless Charger Yes Not Available
Lift Gate Yes Not Available
Electric Fold Indicator Mirrors Yes -
Power Socket 12v Yes -
Sound System 12 6
Roof Rack Compatibility No Not Available
Mirror Electric All Doors
Rim Size 235/60 R18 18-inch BBS Alloy
Stabilizer Bar Front Yes -
Stabilizer Bar Rear Yes -
Sub Frame Unibody Monocoque
Vehicle To Grid Not Available Not Available
One Pedal Driving Not Available Not Available
Regenerative Braking Levels Not Available Not Available
Rear Electric Motor Not Available Not Available
Battery Preconditioning Not Available Not Available
Load Bed Cover Not Available Not Available
Tailgate Lock Not Available Not Available
Sports Bar Not Available Not Available
Canopy Fitment Not Available Not Available
Bed Extender Not Available Not Available
Source Model Column carnival gr86
Intelligent Battery System Not Available Not Available
Front Diff Lock Not Available Not Available
Rear Diff Lock Not Available Not Available
Loadbox Depth Mm Not Available Not Available
Load Bed Light Not Available Not Available
Load Bed Steps Not Available Not Available
Loadbox Rope Hooks Not Available Not Available
Loadbox Tiedown Brackets Not Available Not Available
Tailgate Damper Not Available Not Available
Tow Bar Type Not Available Not Available
Sport Plus Mode Not Available -
Unlocking Yes Standard
Walk Away Lock Yes Standard
Walk Away Auto Door Lock Yes Standard
Rear LED Combination Taillights Yes -
Front Wiper No -
Front Wipers Type No -
Rearview Mirror Inside Yes Standard
Vanity Mirror Illuminated Yes -
Reading Lights Rear Yes -
Centre Console Centre Armrest Standard
Side Impact Bars Yes Standard
Boot Space Seats Folded 2785 l 237 l
Load Bed Length Not Applicable Not Applicable
Load Bed Width Not Applicable Not Applicable
Loadbox Length Mm Not Applicable Not Applicable
Loadbox Width Mm Not Applicable Not Applicable
Spec Carnival GR86
Fuel Octane Requirement B7 Diesel Petrol
Variable Valve Timing No -
Particulate Filter DPF Not Available
Fuel Evaporation Control No -
Idle CO2 Output 198 177
CO2 Emissions 189 g/km 177 g/km
Green NCAP Rating 5 -
Start Stop System Yes Not Available
Euro Emission Standard Euro 6 Euro 5
Noise Level 68 dB 70 dB
CO2 Emissions G Km 189 177
Hybrid System Type Not Available Not Applicable

In depth: how these cars differ

This Carnival and GR86 comparison uses the exact derivatives selected above for South Africa. The catalogue index covers performance, efficiency, safety equipment, practicality and ownership cover only where comparable source-backed fields are present.

Performance index: Carnival 67 vs GR86 67.

Efficiency index: Carnival 55 vs GR86 45.

Safety-equipment index: Carnival 100 vs GR86 96.

Practicality index: Carnival 58 vs GR86 46.

Ownership-cover index: Carnival 71 vs GR86 43.

These figures are Hagalu catalogue-comparison indicators, not customer ratings, crash-test scores, resale guarantees or a substitute for a road test. Each page shows its weighted source coverage beside the result.

Specification Evidence Index

A transparent comparison of published catalogue fields. This is not a road-test score, owner rating or editorial review rating, and it appears only when every vehicle clears the same comparable-data threshold.

Evidence / 100
Evidence-index readout

Carnival leads by 10 points

Carnival has a modest catalogue-index lead, while GR86 remains close.

Evidence leader 71 /100
Lead 10 points
Data 99% source coverage
71
#1 Evidence leader

Carnival

99% source coverage 2 strong categories
Best at Safety 100 Check Efficiency 55
Performance 67
Efficiency 55
Safety 100
Practicality 58
Ownership 71
Leads by 10 points
61
#2

GR86

87% source coverage 1 strong categories
Best at Safety 96 Check Ownership 43
Performance 67
Efficiency 45
Safety 96
Practicality 46
Ownership 43
Performance 24% Safety 22% Practicality 22% Efficiency 17% Ownership 15%
Category leaders What moves the verdict
Performance Level Efficiency Carnival +10 Safety Carnival +4 Practicality Carnival +12 Ownership Carnival +28

Moderate difference in the source-backed catalogue index.

Why this score View full breakdown
Evidence-index leader

Carnival

Performance 67/100
Efficiency 55/100
Safety 100/100
Practicality 58/100
Ownership 71/100

GR86

Performance 67/100
Efficiency 45/100
Safety 96/100
Practicality 46/100
Ownership 43/100

What the evidence means

Evidence index KIA Carnival leads the specification evidence index with 71 pts vs 61 pts for GR86

In Hagalu's specification evidence index, Carnival leads. However, GR86 may suit buyers prioritising different confirmed fields. Ultimately, the right choice depends on your driving priorities in South Africa.

Carnival vs GR86 questions

There is no universal winner. Use the comparison table to match the models and available derivatives in South Africa on price, safety equipment, space, powertrain and ownership cover. The category indicators summarise published catalogue data; they are not a road test or customer rating.

Compare the published consumption or mileage rows for the exact derivatives using the same unit and test basis. A catalogue figure is useful for like-for-like comparison, but traffic, speed, load, weather and driving style can change actual fuel use.

Compare only equipment explicitly listed for each derivative, including airbags, stability control and driver-assistance systems. Confirm the exact trim with the manufacturer, and treat any independent crash-test result separately because equipment and ratings can differ by market.

A reliable five-year total cannot be calculated from catalogue data alone. Add the exact purchase and finance cost, fuel or electricity, insurance quotes, scheduled servicing, tyres and expected resale value. Check whether the selected derivative includes a service or maintenance plan.

Use the seating, boot or load-space, ISOFIX and safety rows as a first check. Then test the exact cars with your child seats, passengers and typical luggage, because published dimensions do not show every access or comfort difference.

Compare the published power, torque and 0–100 km/h rows when they are available for both exact derivatives. Vehicle weight, gearing and power delivery also matter, so catalogue outputs alone do not establish real-world overtaking or response.