A proper head-to-head in South Africa — we cover price, performance,
petrol economy, safety and what it'll actually cost you to own each one long term.
Super Carry starts ZAR 249995 cheaperPicanto Panel Van from ZAR 249,995 · Super Carry from ZAR 197,900
Key Specs Side by Side
The specs that matter most — highlighted where one car leads.
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Engine Power
49
59
Torque
94
104
Engine Size
998
1196
Claimed Mileage
16.4
17.2
Ground Clearance
155
175
Boot Space
620
0
Airbags
6
1 — Driver Only
Kerb Weight
950
850
Seating Capacity
2
2
Warranty
7
5
= leads in this spec
The Overall Score — Here's How They Stack Up
🏆 Winner
#1
Picanto Panel Van
56
/ 100
+21
pts
#2
Super Carry
35
/ 100
Moderate difference between the models.
The Bottom Line
Picanto Panel Van holds a noticeable edge over Super Carry, especially in key ownership areas.
Where They Actually Differ
Performance
Super Carry
+1 pts
Efficiency
Equal
Safety
Picanto Panel Van
+15 pts
Practicality
Picanto Panel Van
+7 pts
Ownership
Equal
Score Breakdown by Category
🏆 Overall Winner
Picanto Panel Van
Performance
4/20
Efficiency
0/20
Safety
18/20
Practicality
14/20
Ownership
20/20
Super Carry
Performance
5/20
Efficiency
0/20
Safety
3/20
Practicality
7/20
Ownership
20/20
What Each Car Gets Right (and Wrong)
🏆 Overall Winner
Picanto Panel Van
Strengths
Stronger safety package
More practical for daily use
Weak Spots
Less powerful engine setup
Best suited to:Family Usage
Super Carry
Strengths
More powerful engine output
Weak Spots
Less comprehensive safety features
Less practical in daily usage
Best suited to:Highway Driving
Which One's Right for You?
Picanto Panel Van
Families prioritising stronger safety equipment
Large families needing more practicality and usability
Super Carry
Drivers who prioritise strong highway performance and overtaking power
Full Specs, Side by Side
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Engine
1.0L G3LA 3-Cylinder Petrol
1.2L GB14 4-Cylinder Petrol
Engine Type
Inline 3 Cylinder Naturally Aspirated
Inline 4 Cylinder Naturally Aspirated
Engine Type Config
1.0L 3-Cylinder DOHC
Available
Engine Code
G3LA
GB14
Cylinder Layout
Inline 3 (I3)
Inline 4 (I4)
Engine Aspiration
Naturally Aspirated
Naturally Aspirated
Displacement
998
1196
Engine Displacement
998
Available
Cylinders
3
4
Valves per Cylinder
4
4
Cylinder Bore
71.0
68.5
Piston Stroke
84.0
81.3
Compression Ratio
10.5:1
9.5:1
Engine Position
Transverse Front-Mounted
Transverse Front-Mounted
Variable Valve Timing
CVVT on Intake Camshaft
Not Available — Fixed Cam Timing
Fuel System
Multi-Point Fuel Injection (MPFI)
Multi-Point Fuel Injection (MPFI)
Turbocharger
Not Applicable
Not Applicable
Power
49
59
Power @ RPM
6,000 rpm
6,000 rpm
Power
66
80
Torque
94
104
Torque @ RPM
3,500 rpm
2,900 rpm
Maximum Engine RPM
6500
6200
Engine Oil Capacity
3.2
3.0
Fuel Grade Required
93 RON Unleaded Petrol
93 RON Unleaded Petrol
Top Speed
148
120
0-100 km/h
14.5
20.0
0–100 km/h
14.5
Available
Battery Capacity
Not Applicable
Available
Charging Port
Not Applicable
Available
AC Charging Time
Not Applicable
Available
EV Range
0
Available
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Valves Per Cylinder
4
Available
Ground Clearance Unladen
155
Available
Fuel Consumption Combined
6.1 L/100km — WLTP Combined Cycle
Available
Spare Wheel
Full Size Spare Tyre
Available
Tyre Repair Kit
No — Full Size Spare Provided
Available
Adaptive Dampers
No
Available
Hill Start Assist
Yes
Available
Seatbelt Pre Tensioner
Yes — Front
Available
Seatbelt Reminder
Yes
Available
Speed Alert System
Yes
Available
Stability Control
Yes
Available
Driver Display
Semi-Digital Instrument Cluster with MID
Available
Steering Mounted Controls
Yes
Available
Multi Function Steering
Yes
Available
Voice Command
Yes
Available
Voice Command Support
Yes
Available
Wireless Charging
No
Not Available
Seat Type
Cloth Fabric
Available
Rear Seat Split
N/A Panel Van
Available
Front Armrest
No
Available
Headrest Adjustable
Yes
Available
Climate Control
Manual Air Conditioning
Manual Air Conditioning (Optional Fitment)
AC Type
Manual AC
Manual Air Conditioning
Climate Zones
Single Zone
1
Power Windows
Yes — Front Windows Only
Not Available — Manual Windows
Keyless Entry
No
Not Available
Push Button Start
No
Not Available
Push Button Start
No
Not Available
Engine Start Stop Button
No
Available
Engine Start Button Illumination
No
Available
Remote Engine Start
No
Available
Sunroof
No
Not Available
Panoramic Roof
No
Not Available
Electric Tailgate
No
Not Available
Boot Opener
Yes — Electric Boot Release Button
Available
Fuel Lid Opener
Yes — Remote Fuel Lid Opener
Available
Automatic Headlamps
Yes
Not Available
Rain Sensing Wipers
No
Not Available
Auto Dimming Mirror
No
Not Available
Auto Dimming Irvm
No
Available
Rear Defogger
Yes
Available
Rear Window Defroster
Yes
Standard
Electric Mirror Folding
No
Manual Fold
Electric Folding Mirrors
No
Available
Power Mirrors
Yes
150
Driver Seat Height Adjustment
Yes
Not Available
Tachometer
Yes
Available
Trip Computer
Yes
Available
Speed Limiter
Yes
Not Available
Follow Me Home Headlamps
Yes
Not Available
12V Accessory Socket
Yes — 12V Front Accessory Socket
1 x 12V Socket
Front Power Outlet
Yes — 12V Socket
150
Rear Reading Lamps
Yes
Available
Vanity Mirror
Yes
Available
Door Ajar Warning
Yes
Available
Impact Sensing Door Unlock
Yes
Available
Engine Check Warning
Yes
Available
Service Reminder
Yes
Available
Rear Wing
No
Available
Chrome Grille
No
Available
Chrome Exterior Highlights
No
Available
Side Steps
No
Available
Skid Plates
No
Available
Gear Shift Type
Floor-Mounted Selector
Available
Engine Start Stop
No
Available
Heads Up Display
No
Not Available
Intercooler
Not Applicable — Naturally Aspirated Engine
Available
Launch Control
No
Available
Performance Data Logger
No
Available
Ride Mode Selection
No
Available
Rev Matching
No
Available
Payload Capacity
Not Applicable — Passenger Vehicle
Available
Roof Antenna
Yes
Available
Aero Kit
No
Available
Exhaust Finish
Standard Single Outlet Chrome Tip
Available
Exhaust Type
Single Exhaust System
Available
Glovebox Cooling
No
Available
Headlamp Height Adjust
Yes — Manual Headlamp Beam Adjustment
Available
Headlamp Washer
No
Available
Drag Coefficient
0.32 Cd
Available
Stabilizer Bar
Front and Rear Anti-Roll Bars
Available
Steering Response
Electric Power Assisted Steering
Available
Tail Lamps
Halogen Tail Lamps
Available
Service Plan
3 Years/45
Available
Engine Warranty
7 Years/150
Available
Telescopic Steering
-
Available
Tilt Steering
-
Available
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Fuel Octane Requirement
93 RON Unleaded
93 RON Unleaded
CO2 Emissions
140
155
Start Stop System
No
Not Available
Noise Level
68
72
Hybrid System Type
Not Applicable
Not Applicable
Particulate Filter
GPF Fitted
Not Fitted
Euro Emission Standard
Euro 5
Euro 5
Green NCAP Rating
Not Independently NCAP Green Rated
Not Rated — Commercial Vehicle
Idle CO2 Output
Within Euro 5 Emission Limits
Within Euro 5 Limits
Fuel Evaporation Control
Evaporative Emission Control (EVAP)
Evaporative Emission Control (EVAP)
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Transmission
4-Speed Automatic
5-Speed Manual
Transmission Type
Automatic
Manual
Transmission
4-Speed Automatic Torque Converter
Available
Number of Gears
4
5
Clutch Type
Torque Converter Automatic
Single Dry Plate Diaphragm
Paddle Shifters
Not Available
Not Available
Final Drive Ratio
4.286:1
4.529:1
Drive Type
FWD
RWD
Drivetrain Layout
Front Wheel Drive
Rear Wheel Drive
Drivetrain
FWD — Front Wheel Drive
Available
Steering Turns Lock to Lock
2.8
3.2
LSD Available
Not Available
Not Available
Differential Lock
Not Available
Not Available
Transfer Case
Not Applicable
Not Applicable
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
4WD System Type
Not Applicable — FWD Only
Not Applicable — RWD Only
Hill Descent Control
No
Available
Approach Angle
17
0
Departure Angle
22
0
Wading Depth
0
0
Terrain Modes
Not Applicable — Urban Hatchback
Not Applicable
Locking Differential
Not Available
Not Available
Underbody Protection
Not Available
Not Available
Ramp Breakover Angle
0
0
Ramp-over Angle
0
Available
Recovery Hooks
1 Rear Tow Hook
1 Rear Tow Hook
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Length
3595
3800
Width
1595
1562
Height
1480
1730
Wheelbase
2400
2110
Ground Clearance
155
175
Kerb Weight
950
850
Gross Vehicle Weight
1400
1280
Max Payload
450
390
Front Track Width
1415
1285
Rear Track Width
1420
1285
Turning Radius
4.8
4.5
Number of Doors
3
4
Doors
3
2
Seats
2
2
Seating Capacity
2
5
Boot Space
620
0
Boot Space Seats Folded
620
1200
Boot Volume
620
0
Towing Capacity
0
0
Load Bed Length
1485
1750
Load Bed Width
1150
1250
Front Legroom
1040
930
Rear Legroom
0
750
Front Headroom
970
1020
Rear Headroom
0
1000
Front Shoulder Room
1355
1200
Rear Shoulder Room
0
1180
Front Overhang
735
Available
Rear Overhang
460
Available
Fuel Tank Capacity
35
Available
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Fuel Tank Capacity
35
30
Claimed Mileage
16.4
17.2
City Mileage
13.5
14.7
Highway Mileage
20.4
20.0
Fuel Efficiency
6.1
Available
Claimed Fuel Consumption
6.1
7.3
Average Fuel Consumption
6.1 L/100km Combined
Available
Real-world Mileage
15.2
Available
Distance To Empty
Yes
Available
Low Fuel Warning
Yes
Available
Emission Standard
Euro 5
Euro 5
AdBlue Tank Capacity
0
0
Auto Start Stop
No
Not Available
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Real-world City Mileage Min
6.9
8.0
Real-world City Mileage Max
8.4
10.0
Real-world Highway Mileage Min
4.5
6.5
Real-world Highway Mileage Max
5.3
8.0
Owner Review Count
0
3
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Tyre Size
175/65 R14
155 R13 LT 8PR
Tyre Type
Tubeless Radial
Available
Wheel Type
Steel Wheels with Hub Caps
Steel Wheels
Wheel Rim Size
14 Inches
13 Inches
Wheel Diameter
14
Available
Front Tyre Width
175
Available
Rear Tyre Width
175
Available
Front Brake Type
Ventilated Disc
Ventilated Disc
Rear Brake Type
Drum
Drum
Brake Type Front
Ventilated Disc
Available
Brake Type Rear
Drum
Available
Front Brake Disc Diameter
247
240
Rear Brake Drum Diameter
180
200
Parking Brake Type
Conventional Handbrake
Conventional Handbrake
Tyre Load Index
82
91
Tyre Speed Rating
T
Q
Spare Wheel Type
Full Size Spare
Full Size Spare
Spare Tyre
Full Size Spare
Available
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Front Suspension
MacPherson Strut with Coil Spring
MacPherson Strut with Coil Spring
Rear Suspension
Coupled Torsion Beam Axle with Coil Spring
Leaf Spring (Commercial Grade)
Chassis Type
Monocoque Unibody Steel Platform
Monocoque
Power Steering
Electric Power Assisted (EPAS)
Electric Power Assisted (EPAS)
Steering Column
Tilt and Telescopic Adjustable
Tilt Adjustable
Front Spring Type
Coil Spring
Coil Spring
Rear Spring Type
Coil Spring
Leaf Spring
Front Anti-Roll Bar
Standard Anti-Roll Bar
Standard
Rear Anti-Roll Bar
Standard Anti-Roll Bar
Not Available
Shock Absorber Type
Telescopic Gas Dampers
Telescopic Hydraulic
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Steering Adjustment
Tilt and Telescopic
Tilt Adjustable
Steering Type
Electric Power Steering
Power Assisted Steering (Hydraulic)
Instrument Cluster Type
Semi-Digital Instrument Cluster
Basic Analogue Gauges
Rear USB Ports
0
0
Seat Material
Cloth
Vinyl
Fabric Seats
Yes
Available
Leather Seats
No
Available
Seat Adjustment
Manual 6-Way Driver Seat Adjustment
Manual 4-Way Driver
Driver Seat Adjustment
6-Way Manual Adjustment
Manual — 7-position slide
Adjustable Driver Seat
Yes
Available
Passenger Seat Adjustment
4-Way Manual Adjustment
Fixed
Adjustable Front Seat
Yes
Available
Memory Seats
No
Available
Heated Seats
No
Not Available
Ventilated Seats
No
Not Available
Cooled Seats
No
Available
Driver Lumbar Support
No
Not Available
Steering Wheel Material
Urethane
Urethane
Ambient Lighting
No
Not Available
Folding Rear Seats
Not Applicable — Panel Van
Rear Bench Folds Flat for Cargo
60 40 Split Seat
No
Available
Front Armrest
No
Not Available
Rear Armrest
No
Not Available
Cup Holders
2
2
Rear AC Vents
No
Not Available
Door Map Pockets
Yes
Driver Door Pocket Only
Front Headrest
Yes — Adjustable
Available
Rear Headrest
Not Applicable
Available
Interior Colour Options
2
1
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Airbags
6
1 — Driver Only
Driver Airbag
Yes
Standard
Passenger Airbag
Yes
Not Available
Side Airbags
Yes — Front Side Airbags
Not Available
Curtain Airbags
Yes — Full Length Curtain Airbags
Not Available
Knee Airbag
No
Available
ABS
Yes
Standard
EBD
Yes
Standard
Electronic Stability Control
Yes
Not Available
TCS
Yes
Not Available
Traction Control
Yes
Not Available
Hill Start Assist
Yes
Not Available
Hill Descent Control
No
Not Available
Brake Assist
Yes
Standard
BA
Yes
Standard
Brake Override System
Yes
Available
Child Safety Lock
Yes
Standard
ISOFIX Mounts
Yes
Not Available
Tyre Pressure Monitor
Yes
Not Available
Engine Immobiliser
Yes
Standard
Engine Immobiliser
Yes
Available
Alarm System
Yes
Not Available
Central Locking
Yes
Standard
Side Impact Beams
Yes
Standard
Seatbelt Warning All Seats
Yes
Front Seats
Seatbelt Pretensioners
Yes — Front Seatbelt Pre-tensioners
Standard — Driver
Speed Alert System
Yes
Not Available
Safety Rating
3 Stars (Euro NCAP 2017 Assessment)
Not Independently Rated — Commercial Vehicle
Whiplash Protection
Yes — Active Head Restraints Front
Basic Head Restraints
Hill Hold
Yes
Not Available
AEB
No
Not Available
Pedestrian Detection AEB
No
Not Available
Blind Spot Monitoring
No
Available
Lane Change Warning
No
Not Available
Rear Cross Traffic Alert
No
Not Available
Fatigue Detection
No
Not Available
Front Parking Sensors
No
Not Available
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Autonomous Emergency Braking
No
Not Available
Blind Spot Monitoring
No
Not Available
Lane Keep Assist
No
Not Available
Lane Departure Warning
No
Not Available
Rear Cross Traffic Alert
No
Not Available
Driver Fatigue Alert
No
Not Available
Traffic Sign Recognition
No
Not Available
Adaptive Cruise Control
No
Not Available
Adaptive Cruise Control
No
Available
Cruise Control
No
Not Available
Auto Highbeam
No
Not Available
Parking Sensors
No
Not Available
Rear Parking Sensors
No
Not Available
Rear View Camera
No
Not Available
Reverse Camera
No
Not Available
360 Degree Camera
No
Not Available
Park Assist
No
Available
Auto Lights
Yes
Not Available
Auto Wipers
No
Not Available
Eco Mode
Yes
Available
Sport Mode
No
Available
Drive Modes
Eco Mode Only
Available
EV Mode
Not Applicable — Petrol Engine
Available
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Infotainment Screen
8-Inch Touchscreen Infotainment System
Basic AM/FM Radio
Infotainment Display
8-Inch Touchscreen Display
Available
Infotainment Screen Size
8
Not Available
Apple CarPlay
Yes
Not Available
Wireless Apple CarPlay
No
Not Available
Android Auto
Yes
Not Available
Bluetooth Connectivity
Yes
Not Available
Navigation System
Yes — Smartphone Navigation via Android Auto/CarPlay
Not Available
Digital Instrument Cluster
Yes — Partial Digital Instrument Cluster
Analogue Instrument Cluster
USB Ports
2
Not Available
Rear Usb
No
Available
Number of Speakers
6
2
Premium Audio
No
Available
FM Radio
Yes
AM/FM Radio Ready
Steering Wheel Audio Controls
Yes
Not Available
Audio Controls On Steering
Yes
Available
Voice Recognition
Yes
Not Available
AUX Input
Yes
Not Available
Wi-Fi Hotspot
No
Not Available
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Body Type
3-Door Panel Van
Flatdeck Pickup — Open Load Bed
LED Headlamps
No
Halogen Headlamps
Led Headlights
No
Halogen
Daytime Running Lamps
Yes — LED Daytime Running Lights
Not Available
DRL
Yes — LED DRL
Not Available
Fog Lamps
No
Not Available
Fog Lights
No
Not Available
Front Fog Lights
No
Not Available
Rear Fog Lights
Yes
Not Available
Led Taillights
No
Halogen
Roof Rails
No
Not Available
Alloy Wheel Design
Standard Design
Steel Wheels with Hub Caps
Chrome Exterior Finish
No
Not Available
Body Cladding
No
Not Applicable
Rear Spoiler
Yes — Rear Integrated Spoiler
Not Available
Exterior Colour Options
5
3
Roof Type
Standard Fixed Roof
Standard Fixed Roof
Wing Mirror Type
Power Adjustable with Integrated Turn Indicators
Manual Mirrors
Rear Wiper
Yes — Standard Rear Wiper and Washer
Not Available
Door Handle Finish
Body-Coloured Door Handles
Standard Black Handles
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Service Interval
15,000 km or 12 Months — Whichever First
10,000 km or 12 Months
Approx Service Cost
Approx R2,500–R3,200 per Service
Approx R1,200–R1,800 per Service
Battery Warranty
12 Months KIA Battery Warranty
12 Months
Battery Type
12V 45Ah Lead-Acid Battery
Available
Maintenance Plan
Included — 3 Years/45
Not Included
Engine Oil Change Interval
10,000 km or 6 Months
10,000 km or 6 Months
First Service At
1,000 km Inspection and Safety Check
1,000 km Inspection
Service Plan Duration
3 Years KIA Service Plan
2 Years
Service Plan Distance
45000
30000
Anti-Rust Treatment
Underbody Anti-Rust Protection
Underbody Rust Protection
Gear Shift Indicator
Yes
Available
Alternator
80A Alternator
Available
Spec
Picanto Panel Van
Super Carry
Warranty Years
7
5
Warranty Kilometers
150000
200000
Roadside Assistance
5 Years Roadside Assistance
5 Years Roadside Assistance
Anti-Corrosion Warranty
5 Years
3 Years Anti-Corrosion
Basic Warranty
7 Years/150
Available
So, Which One Should You Buy?
🏆KIA Picanto Panel Van
wins with 56 pts
vs 35 pts for Super Carry
In structured scoring, Picanto Panel Van emerges as the stronger overall package. However, Super Carry may appeal to buyers prioritising different factors. Ultimately, the right choice depends on your driving priorities in South Africa.
Other Comparisons Worth Checking
See how similar cars go head-to-head — you might find a better fit than you expected.
On our scoring the Picanto Panel Van edges ahead overall. That said, the right choice depends on what you actually use the car for — the breakdown above shows exactly where each one wins and loses.
Efficiency scores: Picanto Panel Van 0 vs Super Carry 0. In the real world, diesel variants of either car will beat the claimed figure on long highways and fall short in Joburg traffic.
Safety scores: Picanto Panel Van 18, Super Carry 3. Check each model page for NCAP ratings and which trim levels include AEB and blind-spot monitoring — those features aren't always standard.
Long-term ownership scores: Picanto Panel Van 20, Super Carry 20. Service intervals, parts availability in SA, and whether a service plan is bundled all factor in — check the individual variant specs for that detail.
Practicality scores: Picanto Panel Van 14, Super Carry 7. This covers boot space, seat flexibility, and day-to-day usability — not just interior dimensions on paper.
Performance scores: Picanto Panel Van 4, Super Carry 5. This looks at real-world pace — 0–100 kph, highway flexibility, and how either car feels when you actually need to overtake on an N-road.
Resale varies with colour, spec, and market timing, but Japanese brands — and Toyota specifically — have a strong track record in SA. Check current used prices for both on AutoTrader to see the real gap right now.
Ground clearance and 4WD availability are what matter most here. Scroll to the spec table above to compare both side by side — if either model offers a 4WD variant, that's the version worth comparing.
Fuel, insurance, and service costs are the big three. Diesel variants of both models typically save R800–R1,500/month in fuel at current SA pump prices. The Picanto Panel Van edges the overall ownership score, but check whether either variant includes a service plan — that changes the monthly maths significantly.
The Picanto Panel Van scores better overall, but neither car is a bad buy here. It comes down to what features matter to you — check the full spec table above to see exactly what you gain and lose at each price point.
In Depth — Breaking It All Down
The comparison between Picanto Panel Van and Super Carry in South Africa
evaluates performance, efficiency, safety, practicality and long-term ownership value.
Performance: Picanto Panel Van scores 4 vs 5.
Efficiency: Picanto Panel Van scores 0 vs 0.
Safety: Picanto Panel Van scores 18 vs 3.
Practicality: Picanto Panel Van scores 14 vs 7.
Ownership: Picanto Panel Van scores 20 vs 20.
Final structured scoring gives Picanto Panel Van
the advantage in this comparison.
Compare
Get Best Price
We'll Contact You
Fill in your details and a dedicated executive will reach out shortly.
✓
We've Got Your Details!
An executive will contact you shortly. Thank you for your interest.
