BYD ATTO 3 vs KIA Carnival
A proper head-to-head in South Africa — compare price, performance, fuel economy or electric range, safety and the details that shape long-term ownership.
Share
BYD ATTO 3
Extended Range EV
Electric
Single-Speed Reduction Gear
Current
ZAR 783,900
ex-showroom
⚡ 150 kW
🔧 310 Nm
VS
KIA Carnival
2.2 CRDi SXL AT
Diesel
8-Speed Automatic
Current
ZAR 1,299,995
ex-showroom
⚡ 148 kW
🔧 440 Nm
⛽ 13.9 km/l
＋
Add a 3rd car
Decision summary
BYD ATTO 3 vs KIA Carnival: the short answer
ATTO 3 and Carnival are close on the comparable published fields, so buyer priorities should decide.
ATTO 3 starts ZAR 350,095 cheaper
ATTO 3 from ZAR 699,900 · Carnival from ZAR 1,049,995
Five key differences
Exact selected derivativesSwipe sideways to compare every column
| Specification | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum Power | ATTO 3150 kW | Carnival148 kW @ 3800 rpm |
| Maximum Torque | ATTO 3310 Nm | Carnival440 Nm @ 1750 rpm |
| Engine Size | ATTO 3Not Applicable | Carnival2151 cc |
| Combined Fuel Economy | ATTO 3Not Applicable | Carnival13.9 km/l |
| Ground Clearance | ATTO 3175 mm | Carnival175 mm |
Strongest published figure in that row; no road-test winner is implied.
Independent editorial assessment
Hagalu editorial ratings
When a variant is selected, its rating out of five applies only to that exact derivative; a model-range review is not inherited. Editorial ratings are separate from the Specification Evidence Index out of 100 and are not customer ratings.
KIA Carnival
2.2 CRDi SXL AT
Hagalu editorial rating
Not yet rated
No complete editorial rating is published for this exact variant. This is not a zero score.
How Hagalu rates cars →Not yet rated means a complete review is not published; it does not mean the vehicle scored zero. Read the rating methodology.
What Each Car Gets Right (and Wrong)
Specification evidence leader
ATTO 3
Strengths
- Better fuel efficiency
Weak Spots
- Less powerful engine setup
- Fewer listed safety features
- Lower published practicality figures
Best suited to:
Published Efficiency
Carnival
Strengths
- More powerful engine output
- Stronger listed safety equipment
- Stronger published practicality figures
Weak Spots
- Lower fuel efficiency
Best suited to:
Published Performance
Published Practicality
Which One's Right for You?
ATTO 3
- Buyers prioritising the lower published fuel or energy use
Carnival
- Buyers prioritising the stronger published powertrain figures
- Buyers prioritising the more complete listed safety equipment
- Buyers prioritising the stronger published space and capacity figures
Full Specs, Side by Side
Open a category, then swipe sideways to compare every column
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Model Introduced Year | 2023 | 2021 |
| Generation | First South African ATTO 3 generation | Fourth generation (KA4); global launch 2020, SA 2021 |
| Facelift History | No separately marketed South African facelift announced as at August 2026 | Fourth generation (KA4) launched SA 2021; 2023 updated specification |
| Facelift Launched Since | Original current-generation version | 2023 |
| Facelift Version Ending | Current | Current |
| Body Style | SUV | MPV |
| Model Year | 2026 | 2026 |
| Production Status | Active | active |
| Segment | Compact SUV | MPV |
| Vehicle Type | Passenger vehicle | MPV |
| Dealer Stock Note | - | Top grade in the South Africa lineup |
| Color Note | - | Snow White Pearl, Aurora Black Pearl, Steel Grey, Gravity Blue, Glacial White Pearl |
| Tare Mass Kg | - | 2110 kg |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Length | 4455 mm | 5155 mm |
| Width | 1875 mm | 1995 mm |
| Height | 1615 mm | 1775 mm |
| Wheelbase | 2720 mm | 3090 mm |
| Ground Clearance (Default) | 175 mm | 175 mm |
| Ground Clearance (With Full Seating Load) | 150 mm | 172 mm |
| Fuel Tank Capacity | 0 l | 72 l |
| Boot/Cargo Space | 310 l | 145 l |
| Kerb Weight | 1750 kg | 2110 kg |
| Gross Vehicle Weight (GVW) | 2160 kg | 2750 kg |
| Payload Capacity | 410 kg | 700 kg |
| Towing Capacity | 750 kg | 1500 kg |
| Seating Capacity | 5 seats | 11 seats |
| Number of Rows | 2 rows | 3 rows |
| Doors | 5 doors | 5 doors |
| Minimum Turning Radius | 5.25 m | 12.1 m |
| Front Headroom | 1010 mm | 1010 mm |
| Rear Headroom | 920 mm | 955 mm |
| Front Legroom | 1070 mm | 1040 mm |
| Rear Legroom | 760 mm | 855 mm |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Engine | Single-motor battery-electric powertrain | 2.2-litre Turbocharged Diesel |
| Engine Code | Not Applicable | D4HB |
| Fuel Type | Electric | Diesel |
| Hybrid System | Not Applicable | Not Applicable |
| Engine Displacement | Not Applicable | 2151 cc |
| Cylinders | Not Applicable | 4 |
| Cylinder Layout | Not Applicable | Inline |
| Valves | Not Applicable | 16 |
| Valves per Cylinder | Not Applicable | 4 |
| Aspiration | Not Applicable | Turbocharged |
| Fuel System | Not Applicable | Common Rail Direct Injection |
| Compression Ratio | Not Applicable | 15.4:1 |
| Bore | Not Applicable | 85.4 mm |
| Stroke | Not Applicable | 94 mm |
| Maximum Power | 150 kW | 148 kW @ 3800 rpm |
| Maximum Torque | 310 Nm | 440 Nm @ 1750 rpm |
| Combined Power | Not Applicable | Not Applicable |
| Combined Torque | Not Applicable | Not Applicable |
| Motor Type | Permanent Magnet Synchronous | Not Applicable |
| Number of Motors | 1 | Not Applicable |
| Motor Location | Front | Not Applicable |
| Drive Type | FWD | FWD |
| Transmission | Single-Speed Reduction Gear | 8-Speed Automatic |
| Top Speed | 160 km/h | 185 km/h |
| 0-100 km/h | 7.3 sec | 10.0 sec |
| Quarter Mile | Not Officially Disclosed | Not Officially Disclosed |
| Drive Modes | Eco, Normal, Sport | Not Officially Disclosed |
| Launch Control | Not Officially Disclosed | No |
| Rev Limiter | Not Applicable | Not Officially Disclosed |
| Power-to-Weight Ratio | 85.7 kW/tonne | 70.1 kW/tonne |
| Torque-to-Weight Ratio | 177.1 Nm/tonne | 208.5 Nm/tonne |
| Battery Capacity | 60.48 kWh | Not Applicable |
| Usable Battery Capacity | Not Officially Disclosed | Not Applicable |
| Battery Type | LFP | Not Applicable |
| Battery Voltage | 403.2 V | Not Applicable |
| Electric Range | 420 km | Not Applicable |
| AC Charging Power | 7 kW | Not Applicable |
| DC Charging Power | 80 kW | Not Applicable |
| AC Charging Time | 9 h 42 min (0-100%) | Not Applicable |
| DC Charging Time | 44 min (10-80%) | Not Applicable |
| Regenerative Braking | Yes | Not Applicable |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Gearbox | Single-Speed Reduction Gear | 8-Speed Automatic |
| Drivetrain Layout | Front motor, front-wheel drive | FWD |
| LSD Available | Not Available | No |
| Transfer Case | Not Applicable | Not Applicable |
| Differential Lock | Not Available | No |
| Paddle Shifters | Not Applicable | No |
| Final Drive Ratio | 3.476 | 3.63 |
| Number of Gears | 1 | 8 |
| Transmission Type | Automatic | Automatic Transmission |
| Clutch Type | Not Applicable | Torque Converter |
| Gear Shift Indicator | Standard | No |
| Gear Shift Type | Gearshift lever | Automatic |
| Drivetrain | FWD | FWD |
| 4WD Engagement | Not Applicable | Not Applicable |
| 4WD Hi Range | Not Applicable | Not Applicable |
| 4WD Lo Range | Not Applicable | Not Applicable |
| 4WD Selector | Not Applicable | Not Applicable |
| Automatic Shift Paddles | Not Applicable | No |
| Front Differential Lock | Not Available | Not Applicable |
| Gearbox Type | Single-speed reduction gear | 8-Speed Automatic |
| Low Range Ratio | Not Applicable | Not Applicable |
| Low Range | Not Applicable | Not Applicable |
| Axle Layout | 4x2 | FWD |
| Rear Differential Lock | Not Applicable | Not Applicable |
| Transmission Speeds | 1 | 8 |
| Engine Position | - | Front Transverse |
| Steering Turns Lock to Lock | - | 15.2:1 |
| Transfer Case Guard | - | Not Available |
| Differential Type Front | - | Not Available |
| Differential Type Rear | - | Not Available |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Claimed Mileage | Not Applicable | 13.9 km/l |
| City Mileage | Not Applicable | 11.1 km/l |
| Highway Mileage | Not Applicable | 16.9 km/l |
| Fuel Tank Capacity | Not Applicable | 72 l |
| Emission Standard | Not Applicable | Euro 6 |
| AdBlue Tank Capacity | Not Applicable | No |
| Auto Start Stop | Not Applicable | Yes |
| Real-world Mileage | Not Applicable | 13.9 km/l |
| Charging Port Type | Type 2 AC; CCS2 DC | Not Applicable |
| Charging Type | AC and DC | Not Applicable |
| Fuel Tank Litres | Not Applicable | 72 |
| Combined Driving Range | 420 km | Not Applicable |
| Electric Consumption | 15.6 kWh/100 km (WLTP) | Not Applicable |
| Range Real World Highway | 310 km | Not Applicable |
| Range Real World Mixed | 390 km | Not Applicable |
| Low Fuel Warning | - | Yes |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Airbags | 7 | 7 |
| ABS | Standard | Yes |
| Electronic Stability Control | Standard | Yes |
| Traction Control | Standard | Yes |
| Hill Descent Control | Standard | Not Available |
| Hill Start Assist | Standard | Yes |
| Child Safety Lock | Standard | Yes |
| ISOFIX Mounts | Standard | Yes |
| Brake Assist | Standard | Yes |
| Tyre Pressure Monitor | Standard | Yes |
| Engine Immobiliser | Standard | Yes |
| Seatbelt Warning All Seats | Standard | Yes |
| Front Parking Sensors | Standard | Yes |
| AEB | Standard | Yes |
| BA | Standard | Yes |
| Brake Override System | Standard | Yes |
| Curtain Airbags | Standard | Yes |
| Driver Airbag | Standard | Yes |
| EBD | Standard | Yes |
| Engine Immobiliser | Not Applicable | Yes |
| Hill Hold | Standard | Yes |
| Passenger Airbag | Standard | Yes |
| Rear Cross Traffic Alert | Standard | Yes |
| Seatbelt Pretensioners | Standard | Yes |
| Seatbelt Reminder | Standard | Yes |
| Side Airbags | Standard | Yes |
| Stability Control | Standard | Yes |
| TCS | Standard | Yes |
| Knee Airbag | Not Available | Yes |
| ABS EBD | Standard | Yes |
| Side Impact Beams | - | Yes |
| Whiplash Protection | - | Yes |
| Pedestrian Detection AEB | - | Yes |
| Lane Change Warning | - | Yes |
| Blind Spot Monitoring | - | Yes |
| Fatigue Detection | - | Yes |
| Speed Alert System | - | Yes |
| Safety Rating | - | 5 |
| Central Locking | - | Yes |
| Alarm System | - | Yes |
| ESC With Traction Control | - | Yes |
| Driver Front Passenger Airbags | - | 7 |
| Driver Passenger Airbags | - | 7 |
| Anti Theft Alarm | - | Yes |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Cruise Control | Standard | Yes |
| Adaptive Cruise Control | Standard | Yes |
| Lane Keep Assist | Standard | Yes |
| Lane Departure Warning | Standard | Yes |
| Blind Spot Monitoring | Standard | Yes |
| Rear Cross Traffic Alert | Standard | Yes |
| Parking Sensors | Standard | Yes |
| Rear View Camera | Standard | Yes |
| 360 Degree Camera | Standard | Yes |
| Autonomous Emergency Braking | Standard | Yes |
| Driver Fatigue Alert | Standard | Yes |
| Traffic Sign Recognition | Standard | No |
| Auto Highbeam | Standard | Yes |
| Auto Wipers | Standard | Yes |
| Rear Parking Sensors | Standard | Yes |
| Reverse Camera | Standard | Yes |
| Adaptive Cruise Control | Standard | Yes |
| Park Assist | Standard | Yes |
| Around View Monitor | Standard | Yes |
| Blind Spot Warning | Standard | Yes |
| Forward Collision Warning | Standard | Yes |
| EV Mode | - | No |
| Reversing Camera | - | Yes |
| Auto Lights | - | Yes |
| Eco Mode | - | Yes |
| Sport Mode | - | No |
| Emergency Braking | - | Yes |
| Pre-Collision System | - | Yes |
| Rear View Camera | - | Yes |
| Reverse Camera Type | - | Yes |
| Surround View Camera | Standard | Yes |
| Parking Distance Sensors | - | Yes |
| Parking Sensor | - | Yes |
| Front Camera | - | Yes |
| Automatic High Beam | - | Yes |
| Rain Sensor Wipers | - | Yes |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Seat Material | Synthetic leather | Leather |
| Heated Seats | Standard | Yes |
| Ventilated Seats | Not Available | Yes |
| Ambient Lighting | Standard | Yes |
| Steering Wheel Material | Synthetic leather | Leather |
| 60 40 Split Seat | Standard | Yes |
| Driver Seat Adjustment | Electric adjustment | 8-Way Power |
| Passenger Seat Adjustment | Electric adjustment | 4-Way Power |
| Seat Trim | Synthetic leather | Leather |
| Front Shoulder Room | - | 1405 mm |
| Rear Shoulder Room | - | 1350 mm |
| Steering Type | - | Yes |
| Steering Adjustment | - | Tilt and Telescopic |
| Rear USB Ports | - | Yes |
| Instrument Cluster Type | - | Digital |
| Rear AC Vents | - | Yes |
| Cooled Seats | - | Yes |
| Fabric Seats | - | No |
| Leather Seats | - | Yes |
| Adjustable Driver Seat | - | 8-Way Power |
| Seat Adjustment | - | 8-Way Power |
| Adjustable Front Seat | - | 4-Way Power |
| Driver Lumbar Support | - | Yes |
| Memory Seats | - | Yes |
| Folding Rear Seats | - | Yes |
| Front Headrest | - | Adjustable |
| Rear Headrest | - | Adjustable |
| Front Armrest | - | Centre Armrest |
| Rear Armrest | - | Yes |
| Door Map Pockets | - | Yes |
| Cup Holders | - | 8 |
| Interior Colour Options | - | Black |
| Interior Courtesy Lamps | - | Power sliding rear doors, business-class second-row captain's chairs, rear entertainment screens (SX), 12.3+12.3-inch curved display, wireless CarPlay, surround-view camera (SX), power-fold third row (SX) |
| Boot Space Seats Down | - | 2785 |
| Seat Belt Warning | - | Yes |
| Leather Accented Seat Trim | - | Leather |
| Driver Seat | - | 8-Way Power |
| Seat Fold Type | - | Yes |
| Armrest Front | - | Centre Armrest |
| Armrest Rear | - | Yes |
| Rear Seat Centre Armrest | - | Yes |
| Interior Colours | - | Black |
| Interior Trim Colour | - | Black |
| Seat Adjustment Driver Backrest | - | Yes |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Climate Control | Automatic | Yes |
| Power Windows | Standard | Yes |
| Keyless Entry | Standard | Yes |
| Push Button Start | Standard | Yes |
| Wireless Charging | Standard | Yes |
| Sunroof | Panoramic | No |
| Electric Tailgate | Standard | Yes |
| Rain Sensing Wipers | Standard | Yes |
| AC Type | Automatic | Yes |
| Intercooler | - | Yes |
| Rev Matching | - | No |
| Performance Data Logger | - | No |
| Fuel Consumption Combined | - | 7.2 |
| Engine Start Stop | Standard | Yes |
| Engine Start Stop Button | Standard | Yes |
| Engine Start Button Illumination | - | Yes |
| Engine Check Warning | - | Yes |
| Drag Coefficient | - | 0.38 |
| Roof Load | - | 100 kg |
| Boot Space Seats Folded | - | 2785 l |
| Stabilizer Bar | - | Yes |
| Steering Response | - | Normal |
| Skid Plates | - | No |
| Side Steps | - | No |
| Spare Wheel | Temporary spare wheel | Temporary Spare |
| Tyre Repair Kit | - | No |
| Seatbelt Pre Tensioner | - | Yes |
| Hill Start Assist | - | Yes |
| Speed Limiter | - | Yes |
| Speed Alert System | - | Yes |
| Impact Sensing Door Unlock | - | Yes |
| Surround View Monitor | Standard | Yes |
| Adaptive Dampers | - | No |
| Voice Command | - | Yes |
| Voice Command Support | - | Yes |
| Digital Speedometer | - | Yes |
| Driver Display | - | Digital Cluster |
| Heads Up Display | - | Yes |
| Tachometer | - | Yes |
| Trip Computer | - | Yes |
| Multi Function Steering | - | Yes |
| Steering Mounted Controls | - | Yes |
| Air Conditioning | Automatic | Yes |
| Climate Zones | - | 3 |
| Rear Air Conditioning | - | Yes |
| Glovebox Cooling | - | No |
| Seat Type | - | Leather Seats |
| Driver Seat Height Adjustment | - | Yes |
| Rear Seat Split | - | Yes |
| Headrest Adjustable | - | Yes |
| Front Armrest | - | Centre Armrest |
| Vanity Mirror | - | Yes |
| 12V Accessory Socket | - | Yes |
| Front Power Outlet | - | Yes |
| Rear Reading Lamps | - | Yes |
| Push Button Start | Standard | Yes |
| Remote Engine Start | - | No |
| Remote Start | - | No |
| Remote Central Locking | - | Yes |
| Door Ajar Warning | - | Yes |
| Fuel Lid Opener | - | Remote |
| Boot Opener | - | Remote |
| Power Mirrors | - | Yes |
| Heated Mirrors | - | Yes |
| Electric Folding Mirrors | - | Yes |
| Electric Mirror Folding | - | Yes |
| Remote Side Mirror | - | Yes |
| Auto Dimming Irvm | - | Yes |
| Auto Dimming Mirror | - | Yes |
| Rear Window Defroster | - | Yes |
| Rear Defogger | - | Yes |
| Follow Me Home Headlamps | - | Yes |
| Tail Lamps | - | Yes |
| Automatic Headlamps | - | Yes |
| Headlamp Height Adjust | - | Yes |
| Headlamp Washer | - | No |
| Panoramic Roof | Panoramic | No |
| Roof Antenna | - | Yes |
| Rear Wing | - | No |
| Aero Kit | - | No |
| Chrome Grille | - | Yes |
| Chrome Exterior Highlights | - | Yes |
| Ride Mode Selection | - | Yes |
| Powered Tailgate | - | Yes |
| Power Sliding Doors | - | No |
| Engine Warranty | - | 7 Years / 150,000 km |
| Service Reminder | - | Yes |
| Trim Level | - | top |
| Variant Role | - | Flagship / premium derivative |
| Vehicle To Load | - | Not Available |
| Accelerator 0 100 | - | 10.0 sec |
| Common Rail Injection | - | Common Rail Direct Injection |
| Diff Lock | - | No |
| Difflock | - | No |
| Vdc | - | Yes |
| TPMS | Standard | Yes |
| Sonar | - | Yes |
| Automatic High Beam | - | Yes |
| Steering Column Adjustment | - | Tilt and Telescopic |
| Tilt Steering | - | Tilt and Telescopic |
| Telescopic Steering | - | Tilt and Telescopic |
| Bottle Holders | - | 8 |
| Glove Box | - | Yes |
| Manual Aircon | - | Yes |
| Intelligent Keyless Entry | - | Yes |
| Passive Entry Start | - | Yes |
| Wireless Charger | Standard | Yes |
| Lift Gate | - | Yes |
| Electric Fold Indicator Mirrors | - | Yes |
| Power Socket 12v | - | Yes |
| Sound System | 8 | 12 |
| Roof Rack Compatibility | - | No |
| Mirror | - | Electric |
| Rim Size | 18 | 235/60 R18 |
| Stabilizer Bar Front | - | Yes |
| Stabilizer Bar Rear | - | Yes |
| Sub Frame | - | Unibody |
| Vehicle To Grid | - | Not Available |
| One Pedal Driving | - | Not Available |
| Regenerative Braking Levels | - | Not Available |
| Rear Electric Motor | - | Not Available |
| Battery Preconditioning | - | Not Available |
| Load Bed Cover | - | Not Available |
| Tailgate Lock | - | Not Available |
| Sports Bar | - | Not Available |
| Canopy Fitment | - | Not Available |
| Bed Extender | - | Not Available |
| Source Model Column | - | carnival |
| Intelligent Battery System | - | Not Available |
| Front Diff Lock | - | Not Available |
| Rear Diff Lock | - | Not Available |
| Loadbox Depth Mm | - | Not Available |
| Load Bed Light | - | Not Available |
| Load Bed Steps | - | Not Available |
| Loadbox Rope Hooks | - | Not Available |
| Loadbox Tiedown Brackets | - | Not Available |
| Tailgate Damper | - | Not Available |
| Tow Bar Type | - | Not Available |
| Sport Plus Mode | - | Not Available |
| Unlocking | Standard | Yes |
| Walk Away Lock | - | Yes |
| Walk Away Auto Door Lock | - | Yes |
| Rear LED Combination Taillights | - | Yes |
| Front Wiper | - | No |
| Front Wipers Type | - | No |
| Rearview Mirror Inside | - | Yes |
| Vanity Mirror Illuminated | - | Yes |
| Reading Lights Rear | - | Yes |
| Centre Console | - | Centre Armrest |
| Side Impact Bars | - | Yes |
| Boot Space Seats Folded | - | 2785 l |
| Load Bed Length | - | Not Applicable |
| Load Bed Width | - | Not Applicable |
| Loadbox Length Mm | - | Not Applicable |
| Loadbox Width Mm | - | Not Applicable |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Infotainment System | 12.8-inch rotating touchscreen | 12.3-inch Touchscreen |
| Apple CarPlay | Standard | Yes |
| Android Auto | Standard | Yes |
| Bluetooth Connectivity | Standard | Yes |
| Number of Speakers | 8 | 12 |
| Digital Instrument Cluster | Full LCD instrument display | Yes |
| USB Ports | Front and rear USB-A/USB-C ports | 4 |
| Infotainment Screen | 12.8 | 12.3 |
| Touchscreen | 12.8 | 12.3 |
| Infotainment Display | - | 12.3 |
| Infotainment Screen Size | 12.8 | 12.3 |
| Navigation System | - | Yes |
| Wireless Apple CarPlay | Standard | Yes |
| Rear Usb | - | Yes |
| AUX Input | - | No |
| Wi-Fi Hotspot | - | No |
| Premium Audio | - | Yes |
| FM Radio | - | Yes |
| Radio | - | Yes |
| Voice Recognition | - | Yes |
| Head Up Display | - | Yes |
| Audio Controls On Steering | - | Yes |
| Steering Wheel Audio Controls | - | Yes |
| Multi Information Display | - | Digital |
| Display Audio | - | 12.3-inch Touchscreen |
| Smartphone Connectivity | - | Yes |
| Connected Services | - | Yes |
| Audio Speakers | 8 | 12 |
| Front Rear USB Charge Ports | - | 4 |
| Voice Control | - | Yes |
| Audio | - | Yes |
| Audio System | - | Yes |
| Wireless Android Auto | Standard | Yes |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| LED Headlamps | Standard | Yes |
| Daytime Running Lamps | LED | Yes |
| Fog Lamps | Rear fog lamp | Yes |
| Roof Rails | Standard | No |
| Exterior Colour Options | Surfing Blue, Cosmos Black, Climbing Grey, Skiing White | Multiple |
| Headlights | Standard | Yes |
| Panoramic Sunroof | Standard | No |
| Front Overhang | - | 938 mm |
| Rear Overhang | - | 1127 mm |
| Body Type | - | MPV |
| Alloy Wheel Design | - | Alloy Alloy |
| Wing Mirror Type | - | Electric |
| Rear Wiper | - | No |
| Led Headlights | Standard | Yes |
| DRL | LED | Yes |
| Led Taillights | - | Yes |
| Fog Lights | - | Yes |
| Front Fog Lights | - | Yes |
| Rear Fog Lights | - | Yes |
| Roof Type | - | Standard |
| Rear Spoiler | - | No |
| Body Cladding | - | No |
| Chrome Exterior Finish | - | Yes |
| Door Handle Finish | - | Body Colour |
| Exterior Colour Options | - | 5 |
| Exterior Mirror Electric | - | Yes |
| Auto Headlights | - | Yes |
| Automatic Headlamps | - | Yes |
| Headlamps | Standard | Yes |
| Headlight Type | Standard | Yes |
| Exterior Mirror Folding | - | Yes |
| Headlamp Levelling | - | Yes |
| Daytime Running Lights | LED | Yes |
| Front Fog Lamps | Rear fog lamp | Yes |
| Rear Spoiler | - | No |
| Exterior Door Handle Colour | - | Body Colour |
| Load Bed Liner | - | Not Available |
| Active Exhaust | - | Not Available |
| Electric Blind Sunroof | - | Standard |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Approach Angle | 19 deg | 16 deg |
| Departure Angle | 24 deg | 17 deg |
| Wading Depth | 346.85 mm | Not Available |
| Terrain Modes | Snow | Not Available |
| Locking Differential | Not Available | No |
| 4WD System Type | Not Applicable | Not Applicable |
| Breakover Angle | 13 deg | 14 deg |
| Ramp Breakover Angle | - | 14 deg |
| Ramp-over Angle | - | 19 deg |
| Recovery Hooks | - | No |
| Underbody Protection | - | No |
| Hill Descent Control | Standard | Not Available |
| Ground Clearance Min | - | 175 mm |
| Ground Clearance Max | - | 175 mm |
| Off Road Descent Control | - | Not Available |
| Terrain Response System | - | Not Available |
| Crawl Control | - | Not Available |
| Underbody Camera | - | Not Available |
| Energy Recovery Display | - | Not Available |
| Terrain Mode Mud | - | Not Available |
| Terrain Mode Normal | - | Not Available |
| Terrain Mode Rock | - | Not Available |
| Terrain Mode Sand | - | Not Available |
| Terrain Mode Snow | - | Not Available |
| Off Road Traction Assist | - | Not Available |
| Skid Plates Transfer Case | - | Not Available |
| Skid Plates Fuel Tank | - | Not Available |
| Front Skid Plate Guard | - | Not Available |
| Rear Skid Plate Guard | - | Not Available |
| Approach Angle Deg | - | 16 deg |
| Departure Angle Deg | - | 17 deg |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Tyre Size | 215/55 R18 | 235/60 R18 |
| Front Brake Type | Ventilated disc | Ventilated Disc |
| Rear Brake Type | Disc | Ventilated Disc |
| Spare Wheel Type | Temporary spare wheel | Temporary Spare |
| Wheel Rim Size | 18 | 235/60 R18 |
| Handbrake Type | Electronic parking brake | Electronic |
| Brake Type Front | - | Ventilated Disc |
| Front Brake Disc Diameter | - | 330 mm |
| Brake Type Rear | - | Ventilated Disc |
| Rear Brake Drum Diameter | - | 296 mm |
| Parking Brake Type | - | Electronic |
| Front Tyre Width | - | 235 mm |
| Rear Tyre Width | - | 235 mm |
| Wheel Diameter | 18 | 235/60 R18 |
| Wheel Type | - | Alloy Alloy |
| Tyre Type | - | Radial |
| Tyre Load Index | - | 112 |
| Tyre Speed Rating | - | H |
| Spare Tyre | Temporary spare wheel | Temporary Spare |
| Tyre Pressure Monitoring | Standard | Yes |
| Tyre Pressure Display | - | Yes |
| Hydraulic Brake Assist | - | Yes |
| Autonomous Emergency Brake | - | Yes |
| Steering Wheel Audio Controls | - | Yes |
| Wheel Material | - | Alloy Alloy |
| Wheels | - | Alloy Alloy |
| Spare Wheel Size Type | - | Temporary Spare |
| Electric Park Brake | - | Electronic |
| Wheel Size Type | - | 235/60 R18 |
| Fifth Wheel Prep | - | Not Available |
| Steering Wheel Cruise Controls | - | Yes |
| Steering Wheel Phone Controls | - | Yes |
| Leather Steering Wheel | - | Leather |
| Steering Wheel Trim | - | Leather |
| Brakes | - | Ventilated Disc |
| Electronic Brakeforce Distribution | - | Yes |
| Cornering Brake Control | - | Yes |
| Auto Brake Hold | - | Electronic |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Front Suspension | MacPherson strut | MacPherson Strut |
| Rear Suspension | Multi-link | Multi-Link |
| Front Track Width | - | 1713 mm |
| Rear Track Width | - | 1711 mm |
| Chassis Type | - | Unibody |
| Front Spring Type | - | Coil Spring |
| Rear Spring Type | - | Coil Spring |
| Shock Absorber Type | - | Telescopic |
| Front Anti-Roll Bar | - | Yes |
| Rear Anti-Roll Bar | - | Yes |
| Power Steering | - | Yes |
| Steering Column | - | Adjustable |
| Front Suspension Type | MacPherson strut | MacPherson Strut |
| Suspension | - | MacPherson Strut |
| Rear Suspension Type | Multi-link | Multi-Link |
| Rear Axle Type | - | Multi-Link |
| Shock Absorbers | - | Telescopic |
| Chassis Material | - | Unibody |
| MagneRide Damping | - | Not Available |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| CO2 Emissions | 0 g/km | 189 g/km |
| Fuel Octane Requirement | - | B7 Diesel |
| Variable Valve Timing | - | No |
| Particulate Filter | - | DPF |
| Fuel Evaporation Control | - | No |
| Idle CO2 Output | - | 198 |
| Green NCAP Rating | - | 5 |
| Start Stop System | - | Yes |
| Euro Emission Standard | - | Euro 6 |
| Noise Level | - | 68 dB |
| CO2 Emissions G Km | - | 189 |
| Hybrid System Type | - | Not Available |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Service Plan | 4 years/80000 km service plan; 5 years/100000 km maintenance plan | 3 Years / 45,000 km |
| Alternator | - | Yes |
| Engine Oil Capacity | - | 6.0 l |
| Engine Oil Change Interval | - | 15000 |
| Service Plan Duration | 4 years/80000 km service plan; 5 years/100000 km maintenance plan | 3 Years / 45,000 km |
| Service Plan Distance | 4 years/80000 km service plan; 5 years/100000 km maintenance plan | 3 Years / 45,000 km |
| Maintenance Plan | - | 3 Years / 45,000 km |
| Service Interval | - | 15000 |
| First Service At | - | 15000 |
| Approx Service Cost | - | R4,500 per service |
| Anti-Rust Treatment | - | Yes |
| Service Intervals | - | 15000 |
| Battery Warranty | - | 7 Years / 150,000 km |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership Role | extended-range derivative | Top |
| Price Zar | 783900 ZAR | 1299995 ZAR |
| Pricing Role | extended-range derivative | Current listed price |
| Starting Price | 783900 | 1299995 |
| Starting Price Zar | 783900 | 1299995 |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Warranty | 5 years/100000 km complete vehicle; 8 years/200000 km power battery; 5 years/100000 km drive unit | 7 Years / 150,000 km |
| Basic Warranty | 5 years/100000 km complete vehicle; 8 years/200000 km power battery; 5 years/100000 km drive unit | 7 Years / 150,000 km |
| Warranty Years | 5 years/100000 km complete vehicle; 8 years/200000 km power battery; 5 years/100000 km drive unit | 7 Years / 150,000 km |
| Warranty Kilometers | 5 years/100000 km complete vehicle; 8 years/200000 km power battery; 5 years/100000 km drive unit | 7 Years / 150,000 km |
| Anti-Corrosion Warranty | - | 5 Years |
| Roadside Assistance | - | 5 Years |
| Roadside Assistance | - | 5 Years |
| Warranty Roadside Assistance | - | 5 Years |
| Spec | ATTO 3 | Carnival |
|---|---|---|
| Real-world City Mileage Min | - | 9.4 l/100km |
| Real-world City Mileage Max | - | 12.2 l/100km |
| Real-world Highway Mileage Min | - | 15.3 l/100km |
| Real-world Highway Mileage Max | - | 17.8 l/100km |
In depth: how these cars differ
This ATTO 3 and Carnival comparison uses the exact derivatives selected above for South Africa. The catalogue index covers performance, efficiency, safety equipment, practicality and ownership cover only where comparable source-backed fields are present.
Performance index: ATTO 3 65 vs Carnival 67.
Efficiency index: ATTO 3 90 vs Carnival 55.
Safety-equipment index: ATTO 3 99 vs Carnival 100.
Practicality index: ATTO 3 51 vs Carnival 58.
Ownership-cover index: ATTO 3 not separately scored vs Carnival 71.
These figures are Hagalu catalogue-comparison indicators, not customer ratings, crash-test scores, resale guarantees or a substitute for a road test. Each page shows its weighted source coverage beside the result.
Model imagery
ATTO 3 and Carnival image comparison
Open an image for its full canonical file or visit the model page for the complete vehicle record.
BYD ATTO 3
View 8 more ATTO 3 images
KIA Carnival
View 8 more Carnival images
Specification Evidence Index
A transparent comparison of published catalogue fields. This is not a road-test score, owner rating or editorial review rating, and it appears only when every vehicle clears the same comparable-data threshold.
Evidence-index readout
ATTO 3 leads by 4 points
ATTO 3 and Carnival are close on the comparable published fields, so buyer priorities should decide.
Evidence leader
75
/100
Lead
4
points
Data
69%
source coverage
75
#1
Evidence leader
ATTO 3
69% source coverage
2 strong categories
Best at
Safety 99
Check
Practicality 51
Performance
65
Efficiency
90
Safety
99
Practicality
51
Leads by 4 points
71
#2
Carnival
99% source coverage
2 strong categories
Best at
Safety 100
Check
Efficiency 55
Performance
67
Efficiency
55
Safety
100
Practicality
58
Ownership
71
Performance 24%
Safety 22%
Practicality 22%
Efficiency 17%
Ownership 15%
Category leaders
What moves the verdict
Performance
Carnival +2
Efficiency
ATTO 3 +35
Safety
Carnival +1
Practicality
Carnival +7
Close catalogue match. Buyer priorities should decide the outcome.
Why this score View full breakdown
Evidence-index leader
ATTO 3
Performance
65/100
Efficiency
90/100
Safety
99/100
Practicality
51/100
Carnival
Performance
67/100
Efficiency
55/100
Safety
100/100
Practicality
58/100
Ownership
71/100
What the evidence means
Evidence index
BYD ATTO 3
leads the specification evidence index with 75 pts
vs 71 pts for Carnival
In Hagalu's specification evidence index, ATTO 3 leads. However, Carnival may suit buyers prioritising different confirmed fields. Ultimately, the right choice depends on your driving priorities in South Africa.
Related comparisons
Continue with closely related South Africa models and comparable body styles.
ATTO 3 vs Carnival questions
There is no universal winner. Use the comparison table to match the models and available derivatives in South Africa on price, safety equipment, space, powertrain and ownership cover. The category indicators summarise published catalogue data; they are not a road test or customer rating.
Compare the published consumption or mileage rows for the exact derivatives using the same unit and test basis. A catalogue figure is useful for like-for-like comparison, but traffic, speed, load, weather and driving style can change actual fuel use.
Compare only equipment explicitly listed for each derivative, including airbags, stability control and driver-assistance systems. Confirm the exact trim with the manufacturer, and treat any independent crash-test result separately because equipment and ratings can differ by market.
A reliable five-year total cannot be calculated from catalogue data alone. Add the exact purchase and finance cost, fuel or electricity, insurance quotes, scheduled servicing, tyres and expected resale value. Check whether the selected derivative includes a service or maintenance plan.
Use the seating, boot or load-space, ISOFIX and safety rows as a first check. Then test the exact cars with your child seats, passengers and typical luggage, because published dimensions do not show every access or comfort difference.
Compare the published power, torque and 0–100 km/h rows when they are available for both exact derivatives. Vehicle weight, gearing and power delivery also matter, so catalogue outputs alone do not establish real-world overtaking or response.