A proper head-to-head in South Africa — we cover price, performance,
petrol economy, safety and what it'll actually cost you to own each one long term.
Grand i10 starts ZAR 373800 cheaperGrand i10 from ZAR 218,900 · Polo from ZAR 373,800
Key Specs Side by Side
The specs that matter most — highlighted where one car leads.
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Engine Power
61 kW
147 kW
Torque
114 Nm
320 Nm
Engine Size
1197 cc
2000 cc
Claimed Mileage
16.9 km/l
18.9 km/l
Ground Clearance
170 mm
133 mm
Boot / Load Bay
235 l
305 l
Airbags
6
6
Kerb Weight
975 kg
1247 kg
Seating Capacity
5
5
Warranty
5
3 years / 120 000 km
= leads in this spec
The Bottom Line
Both Grand i10 and Polo are extremely closely matched, making the final choice dependent on buyer preference.
Where They Actually Differ
Performance
Polo
+35 pts
Efficiency
Polo
+5 pts
Safety
Grand i10
+31 pts
Practicality
Equal
Ownership
Grand i10
+39 pts
What Each Car Gets Right (and Wrong)
🏆 Overall Winner
Grand i10
Strengths
Stronger safety package
Better long-term ownership value
Weak Spots
Less powerful engine setup
Lower fuel efficiency
Best suited to:General Use
Polo
Strengths
More powerful engine output
Better fuel efficiency
Weak Spots
Less comprehensive safety features
Shorter warranty coverage
Best suited to:Highway DrivingFuel Efficiency
Which One's Right for You?
Grand i10
Families prioritising stronger safety equipment
Long-term owners valuing warranty and ownership peace of mind
Polo
Drivers who prioritise strong highway performance and overtaking power
Buyers looking for better fuel efficiency
Full Specs, Side by Side
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Model Introduced Year
2014
2018
Generation
Second generation Grand i10 sold in SA with a 2023 facelift; based on the global third-gen i10 platform adapted for emerging markets
Sixth generation Polo on MQB-A0 platform
Facelift History
Second generation arrived in 2017; facelift with updated front styling and infotainment in 2023
Facelift in 2022 with updated tech and styling
Facelift Launched Since
2023
2022
Facelift Version Ending
Current
Current
Body Style
Hatchback
Hatchback
Color Note
White, Silver, Red, Blue, Grey
White, Black, Silver, Grey, Blue, Red
Dealer Stock Note
Fluid grade in the South Africa lineup
Flagship grade in the South Africa lineup
Model Year
2026
Current
Production Status
published
published
Segment
Hatchback
Hatchback
Vehicle Type
Hatchback
Hatchback
Drivetrain Note
-
4x2 configuration for the local line-up
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Ground Clearance
170 mm
133 mm
Wheelbase
2385 mm
2549 mm
Length
3665 mm
4074 mm
Width
1660 mm
1751 mm
Height
1520 mm
1431 mm
Kerb Weight
975 kg
1247 kg
Gross Vehicle Weight
1410 kg
1780 kg
Seating Capacity
5
5
Boot Space
235 l
305 l
Towing Capacity
-
-
Front Track Width
-
1501 mm
Rear Track Width
-
1484 mm
Turning Radius
-
10.6 m
Load Bed Length
235 l
305 l
Load Bed Width
-
-
Front Legroom
-
-
Rear Legroom
-
-
Front Headroom
-
-
Rear Headroom
-
-
Front Shoulder Room
-
-
Rear Shoulder Room
-
-
Boot Space Seats Folded
235 l
305 l
Number of Doors
5
5
Max Payload
-
-
Boot Volume
235 l
305 l
Doors
5
5
Seats
5
5
Fuel Tank Capacity
35 l
40 l
Gross Vehicle Mass Kg
1410 kg
1780 kg
Ground Clearance Max
170 mm
133 mm
Ground Clearance Min
170 mm
133 mm
Ground Clearance Mm
170 mm
133 mm
Height Mm
1520 mm
1431 mm
Length Mm
3665 mm
4074 mm
Loadbox Length Mm
235 l
305 l
Loadbox Width Mm
-
-
Payload Kg
-
-
Cargo Volume
235 l
305 l
Tare Mass Kg
975 kg
1247 kg
Turning Circle
-
10.6 m
Turning Circle M
-
10.6 m
Width Mm
1660 mm
1751 mm
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Engine
1.2 MPI DOHC
3-cylinder SI engine 1.0 l TSI, 70 kW; 2.0 TSI GTI DSG 147kW
Engine Type
Petrol
3-cylinder SI engine 1.0 l TSI, 70 kW; 2.0 TSI GTI DSG 147kW
Displacement
1197 cc
2000 cc
Cylinders
4
-
Valves per Cylinder
12
-
Power
61 kW
147 kW
Power @ RPM
6300
-
Torque
114 Nm
320 Nm
Torque @ RPM
4200
175
Fuel System
Multi-Point Fuel Injection
-
Turbocharger
No
-
Top Speed
171 km/h
-
0-100 km/h
12.8 sec
-
Compression Ratio
-
-
Engine Position
Front
-
Cylinder Bore
-
-
Piston Stroke
-
-
Engine Code
-
-
Power
82 bhp
197 bhp
Fuel Grade Required
Petrol
Petrol
Cylinder Layout
-
-
Engine Aspiration
Naturally Aspirated
-
Variable Valve Timing
Yes
-
Engine Type Config
Inline
3-cylinder SI engine 1.0 l TSI, 70 kW; 2.0 TSI GTI DSG 147kW
0–100 km/h
12.8 sec
-
Battery Capacity
-
-
Charging Port
-
-
AC Charging Time
-
-
Engine Displacement
1197 cc
2000 cc
Engine Displacement Litres
1197 cc
2000 cc
EV Range
-
-
Acceleration 0 100
12.8 sec
-
Combined System Power
-
-
Combined System Torque
-
-
Engine Config
1.2 MPI DOHC
3-cylinder SI engine 1.0 l TSI, 70 kW; 2.0 TSI GTI DSG 147kW
Engine Cylinders
4
-
Engine Displacement Cc
1197 cc
2000 cc
Engine Power kW
61 kW
147 kW
Engine Torque Nm
114 Nm
320 Nm
Engine Valves
12
-
Induction
Naturally Aspirated
-
Max Power kW
61 kW
147 kW
Max Torque Nm
114 Nm
320 Nm
Maximum Power
61 kW
147 kW
Maximum Torque
114 Nm
320 Nm
Motor Position
-
-
Motor Power
-
-
Motor Torque
-
-
Motor Type
-
-
Power Assisted Steering
MDPS Electric
Standard
Power kW Rpm
6300
-
System Output
-
-
Torque Nm Rpm
4200
175
Turbo Type
Naturally Aspirated
-
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Transmission
Manual
Automatic
Drive Type
Front-Wheel Drive
4x2
Drivetrain Layout
FWD
4x2
LSD Available
No
-
Transfer Case
-
-
Differential Lock
No
-
Paddle Shifters
No
-
Final Drive Ratio
-
-
Number of Gears
5 km/h
-
Transmission Type
Manual
Automatic
Clutch Type
-
-
Drivetrain
Front-Wheel Drive
4x2
Transmission
Manual
Automatic
4WD Engagement
-
-
4WD Hi Range
-
-
4WD Lo Range
-
-
4WD Selector
-
-
Automatic Shift Paddles
No
-
Differential Type Front
-
-
Differential Type Rear
-
-
Front Differential Lock
-
-
Gearbox Type
Manual
Automatic
Low Range
-
-
Axle Layout
Front-Wheel Drive
4x2
Rear Differential Lock
-
-
Transfer Case Guard
-
-
Transmission Speeds
5 km/h
-
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Claimed Mileage
16.9 km/l
18.9 km/l
City Mileage
13.9 km/l
15.5 km/l
Highway Mileage
19.6 km/l
21.9 km/l
Fuel Tank Capacity
35 l
40 l
Emission Standard
Euro 6
-
AdBlue Tank Capacity
-
-
Auto Start Stop
No
-
Average Fuel Consumption
5.9 l/100km
5.3 l/100km
Claimed Fuel Consumption
5.9 l/100km
5.3 l/100km
Distance To Empty
Yes
-
Low Fuel Warning
Yes
-
Fuel Efficiency
5.9 l/100km
5.3 l/100km
Real-world Mileage
16.9 km/l
18.9 km/l
AC Charging Power
-
-
Charging Port Type
-
-
Charging Time AC Full
-
-
Charging Time DC Fast 80pct
-
-
Charging Type
-
-
Combined Consumption
5.9 l/100km
5.3 l/100km
Combined Consumption L 100km
5.9 l/100km
5.3 l/100km
DC Charging Power
-
-
Fuel Economy Combined
5.9 l/100km
5.3 l/100km
Fuel Tank Litres
35 l
40 l
Fuel Type
Petrol
Petrol
Low Range Ratio
-
-
Combined Driving Range
-
-
Electric Consumption
-
-
Range Real World Highway
-
-
Range Real World Mixed
-
-
Range Wltp
-
-
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Airbags
6
6
ABS
Yes
Standard
Electronic Stability Control
Yes
-
Traction Control
Yes
-
Hill Descent Control
No
-
Hill Start Assist
Yes
-
Child Safety Lock
Yes
-
ISOFIX Mounts
Yes
-
Brake Assist
Yes
-
Tyre Pressure Monitor
Yes
-
Engine Immobiliser
Yes
-
Alarm System
Yes
-
Central Locking
Yes
-
Seatbelt Warning All Seats
Yes
-
Speed Alert System
Yes
-
Front Parking Sensors
-
Standard
Safety Rating
Not Rated (SA)
-
AEB
No
-
BA
Yes
-
Brake Override System
-
-
Curtain Airbags
-
-
Driver Airbag
Yes
-
EBD
Yes
Standard
Engine Immobiliser
Yes
-
Hill Hold
Yes
-
Passenger Airbag
Yes
-
Rear Cross Traffic Alert
No
-
Seatbelt Pretensioners
Yes
-
Side Airbags
-
-
TCS
Yes
-
Blind Spot Monitoring
No
-
Knee Airbag
-
-
ABS EBD
Yes
Standard
Anti Theft Alarm
Yes
-
Driver Front Passenger Airbags
6
-
Driver Passenger Airbags
6
-
ESC With Traction Control
Yes
-
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Cruise Control
Yes
Standard
Adaptive Cruise Control
No
-
Lane Keep Assist
No
-
Lane Departure Warning
No
-
Blind Spot Monitoring
No
-
Rear Cross Traffic Alert
No
-
Parking Sensors
Rear
Front and rear
Rear View Camera
Yes
Standard
360 Degree Camera
-
-
Autonomous Emergency Braking
No
-
Driver Fatigue Alert
-
-
Traffic Sign Recognition
No
-
Auto Highbeam
-
-
Auto Lights
Yes
-
Auto Wipers
No
-
Drive Modes
Eco / Normal
-
Eco Mode
Yes
-
EV Mode
No
-
Rear Parking Sensors
Rear
Standard
Reverse Camera
Yes
Standard
Sport Mode
No
-
Adaptive Cruise Control
No
-
Park Assist
-
-
Around View Monitor
-
-
Blind Spot Warning
No
-
Emergency Braking
No
-
Forward Collision Warning
-
-
Parking Distance Sensors
Rear
-
Parking Sensor
Rear
-
Pre-Collision System
No
-
Rain Sensor Wipers
No
-
Rear View Camera
Yes
Standard
Reverse Camera Type
Yes
-
Reversing Camera
Yes
Standard
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Seat Material
Fabric
Cloth
Seat Adjustment
Manual
-
Heated Seats
No
-
Ventilated Seats
No
-
Steering Type
Electric
Standard
Steering Adjustment
Tilt
-
Ambient Lighting
No
-
Folding Rear Seats
60/40 Split
-
Front Armrest
Yes
Centre console
Rear Armrest
No
-
Cup Holders
4
-
Rear AC Vents
No
-
Rear USB Ports
2
-
Steering Wheel Material
Leather
Standard
Instrument Cluster Type
Analogue + MID
-
Interior Colour Options
5
Black
Door Map Pockets
Yes
-
60 40 Split Seat
Yes
-
Adjustable Driver Seat
Manual
-
Adjustable Front Seat
Manual
-
Cooled Seats
No
-
Driver Seat Adjustment
Manual
-
Fabric Seats
Yes
Cloth
Front Headrest
Yes
-
Leather Seats
No
-
Memory Seats
No
-
Passenger Seat Adjustment
Manual
-
Rear Headrest
Yes
-
Armrest Front
Yes
-
Armrest Rear
No
-
Boot Space Seats Up
235
-
Cargo Space
235
-
Driver Seat
Manual
-
Interior Courtesy Lamps
Touchscreen infotainment with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto on upper trims, simple and practical cabin layout, adequate rear legroom for a sub-compact
Digital cockpit, infotainment screen, Apple CarPlay & Android Auto, quality cabin materials
Leather Accented Seat Trim
Fabric
-
Interior Colours
5
Black
Rear Seat Centre Armrest
No
-
Seat Belt Warning
Yes
-
Seat Capacity
5
5
Seat Count
5
5
Seat Fold Type
60/40 Split
-
Seat Trim
Fabric
Cloth
Interior Trim Colour
-
Black
Floor Mats
-
Standard
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Climate Control
Manual AC
Standard
Power Windows
All
-
Keyless Entry
Yes
-
Push Button Start
No
-
Wireless Charging
No
-
Sunroof
No
-
Electric Tailgate
-
-
Automatic Headlamps
Yes
-
Rain Sensing Wipers
No
-
Auto Dimming Mirror
No
-
Rear Window Defroster
Yes
-
Electric Mirror Folding
Power Adjustable
-
Follow Me Home Headlamps
Yes
-
12V Accessory Socket
12V
Standard
AC Type
Manual AC
Standard
Auto Dimming Irvm
No
-
Boot Opener
Inside
-
Climate Zones
1
Standard
Door Ajar Warning
Yes
-
Electric Folding Mirrors
Yes
-
Engine Check Warning
Yes
-
Engine Start Button Illumination
No
-
TPMS
Yes
-
Engine Start Stop
No
-
Engine Start Stop Button
No
-
Engine Warranty
4
-
Front Armrest
Yes
Centre console
Front Power Outlet
Yes
Standard
Fuel Consumption Combined
5.9
5.3
Fuel Lid Opener
Inside
-
Gear Shift Type
5-speed Manual
DCT
Glovebox Cooling
Yes
-
Ground Clearance Unladen
170
-
Headlamp Height Adjust
Manual
-
Headlamp Washer
No
-
Hill Start Assist
Yes
-
Panoramic Roof
No
-
Power Mirrors
Yes
-
Push Button Start
No
-
Rear Defogger
Yes
-
Rear Reading Lamps
Yes
-
Rear Seat Split
60/40 Split
-
Rear Wing
Yes
-
Seat Type
Fabric
-
Seatbelt Pre Tensioner
Yes
-
Seatbelt Reminder
Yes
-
Service Plan
3 Years / 45000 km
-
Service Reminder
Yes
-
Skid Plates
-
-
Spare Wheel
Full Size
-
Stability Control
Yes
-
Steering Mounted Controls
Yes
-
Tachometer
Yes
-
Telescopic Steering
No
-
Tilt Steering
Yes
-
Trip Computer
Yes
-
Valves Per Cylinder
12
-
Vanity Mirror
Yes
-
Voice Command
Yes
-
Voice Command Support
Yes
-
Accelerator 0 100
12.8 sec
-
Air Conditioning
Manual AC
Standard
Battery Preconditioning
-
-
Battery Voltage
-
-
Bed Extender
-
-
Bottle Holders
4
-
Canopy Fitment
-
-
Centre Console
Yes
Standard
Common Rail Injection
Multi-Point Fuel Injection
-
Diff Lock
No
-
Difflock
No
-
Digital Speedometer
Analogue + MID
-
Front Diff Lock
-
-
Front Wiper
Yes
-
Front Wipers Type
Yes
-
Glove Box
Yes
-
Intelligent Battery System
-
-
Intelligent Keyless Entry
Yes
-
Load Bed Cover
-
-
Load Bed Light
-
-
Load Bed Steps
-
-
Loadbox Depth Mm
-
-
Loadbox Rope Hooks
-
-
Loadbox Tiedown Brackets
-
-
Manual Aircon
Manual AC
Standard
Mirror
Power Adjustable
-
One Pedal Driving
-
-
Passive Entry Start
Yes
-
Power Socket 12v
12V
Standard
Reading Lights Rear
Yes
-
Rear Air Conditioning
No
-
Rear Diff Lock
-
-
Rear Electric Motor
-
-
Rearview Mirror Inside
No
-
Regenerative Braking
-
-
Regenerative Braking Levels
-
-
Remote Central Locking
Yes
-
Remote Side Mirror
Power Adjustable
-
Rim Size
14
-
Roof Rack Compatibility
No
-
Sonar
Rear
-
Sound System
6
-
Source Model Column
grand-i10
polo
Sports Bar
-
-
Steering Column Adjustment
Tilt
-
Sub Frame
Monocoque
-
Tailgate Damper
-
-
Tailgate Lock
-
-
Tow Bar Type
-
-
Trim Level
fluid
flagship
Unlocking
Yes
-
Vanity Mirror Illuminated
Yes
-
Variant Role
Mid-to-high value derivative
Performance-focused derivative
Vdc
Yes
-
Vehicle To Grid
-
-
Vehicle To Load
-
-
Walk Away Auto Door Lock
Yes
-
Walk Away Lock
Yes
-
Wireless Charger
No
-
Multi Function Steering
-
Standard
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Infotainment Screen
8-inch Touchscreen
SYNC
Apple CarPlay
Yes
-
Android Auto
Yes
-
Bluetooth Connectivity
Yes
-
Number of Speakers
6
-
Navigation System
Yes
-
Digital Instrument Cluster
No
-
USB Ports
2
-
Wireless Apple CarPlay
Yes
-
FM Radio
Yes
-
Steering Wheel Audio Controls
Yes
-
Voice Recognition
Yes
-
AUX Input
Yes
-
Infotainment Screen Size
8-inch Touchscreen
SYNC
Audio Controls On Steering
Yes
-
Infotainment Display
Touchscreen
-
Rear Usb
Yes
-
Audio
Yes
-
Audio Speakers
6
-
Audio System
Yes
-
Display Audio
8-inch Touchscreen
-
Front Rear USB Charge Ports
2
-
Infotainment Screen
8-inch Touchscreen
SYNC
Multi Information Display
Analogue + MID
-
Connected Services
Yes
SYNC
Voice Control
Yes
-
Smartphone Connectivity
Yes
-
Radio
Yes
-
Touchscreen
8-inch Touchscreen
SYNC
Wireless Android Auto
Yes
-
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
LED Headlamps
Yes
-
Daytime Running Lamps
LED
-
Fog Lamps
Yes
-
Roof Rails
No
-
Alloy Wheel Design
14-inch Alloy
-
Rear Spoiler
Yes
-
Exterior Colour Options
5
6
Roof Type
No
-
Wing Mirror Type
Power Adjustable
-
Rear Wiper
Yes
-
Door Handle Finish
Body Coloured
-
Body Type
Hatchback
Hatchback
DRL
LED
-
Fog Lights
Yes
-
Front Fog Lights
Yes
-
Led Headlights
Yes
-
Auto Headlights
Yes
-
Automatic Headlamps
Yes
-
Daytime Running Lights
LED
-
Electric Blind Sunroof
No
-
Exterior Colour Options
5
6
Exterior Door Handle Colour
Body Coloured
-
Exterior Mirror Electric
Yes
-
Exterior Mirror Folding
Power Adjustable
-
Front Fog Lamps
Yes
-
Headlamp Levelling
Yes
-
Headlamps
Yes
-
Headlight Type
Yes
-
Headlights
Yes
-
Load Bed Liner
-
-
Panoramic Sunroof
No
-
Rear Spoiler
Yes
-
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Approach Angle
-
-
Departure Angle
-
-
Wading Depth
-
-
Terrain Modes
-
-
Locking Differential
No
-
Underbody Protection
-
-
Ramp Breakover Angle
20 deg
-
4WD System Type
Front-Wheel Drive
4x2
Hill Descent Control
No
-
Ramp-over Angle
20 deg
-
Approach Angle Deg
-
-
Breakover Angle
20 deg
-
Departure Angle Deg
-
-
Energy Recovery Display
-
-
Front Skid Plate Guard
-
-
Off Road Descent Control
-
-
Off Road Traction Assist
-
-
Crawl Control
-
-
Rear Skid Plate Guard
-
-
Skid Plates Fuel Tank
-
-
Skid Plates Transfer Case
-
-
Terrain Mode Mud
-
-
Terrain Mode Normal
-
-
Terrain Mode Rock
-
-
Terrain Mode Sand
-
-
Terrain Mode Snow
-
-
Terrain Response System
-
-
Underbody Camera
-
-
Wading Depth Mm
-
-
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Tyre Size
175/65 R14
-
Wheel Type
14-inch Alloy
-
Front Brake Type
Disc
-
Rear Brake Type
Drum
-
Spare Wheel Type
Full Size
-
Parking Brake Type
Manual
-
Tyre Load Index
91
-
Tyre Speed Rating
H
-
Wheel Rim Size
14
-
Brake Type Front
Disc (Ventilated)
-
Brake Type Rear
Disc
-
Spare Tyre
Full Size
-
Tyre Type
Tubeless Radial
-
Wheel Diameter
14
-
Auto Brake Hold
Manual
-
Autonomous Emergency Brake
No
-
Brakes
Disc
-
Cornering Brake Control
Yes
-
Electric Park Brake
Manual
-
Electronic Brakeforce Distribution
Yes
-
Fifth Wheel Prep
-
-
Handbrake Type
Manual
-
Hydraulic Brake Assist
Yes
-
Leather Steering Wheel
Leather
Standard
Spare Wheel Size Type
Full Size
-
Steering Wheel Audio Controls
Yes
-
Steering Wheel Cruise Controls
Yes
-
Steering Wheel Phone Controls
Yes
-
Steering Wheel Trim
Leather
Standard
Tyre Pressure Display
Yes
-
Tyre Pressure Monitoring
Yes
-
Wheel Material
14-inch Alloy
-
Wheel Size Type
14
-
Wheelbase Mm
2385 mm
2549 mm
Wheels
14-inch Alloy
-
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Front Suspension
MacPherson Strut
-
Rear Suspension
Torsion Beam
-
Chassis Type
Monocoque
-
Power Steering
Electric
Standard
Steering Column
Tilt
-
Front Spring Type
MacPherson Strut
-
Rear Spring Type
Torsion Beam
-
Chassis Material
Monocoque
-
Front Suspension Type
MacPherson Strut
-
Rear Axle Type
Torsion Beam
-
Rear Suspension Type
Torsion Beam
-
Suspension
MacPherson Strut
-
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Service Interval
15000 km / 12 months
-
Battery Warranty
4
-
Maintenance Plan
3 Years / 45000 km
-
Engine Oil Change Interval
15000 km / 12 months
-
First Service At
15000
-
Service Plan Duration
3 Years / 45000 km
-
Service Plan Distance
3 Years / 45000 km
-
Alternator
120A
-
Battery Type
Lead-acid
-
Gear Shift Indicator
Yes
-
Service Intervals
15000 km / 12 months
-
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Warranty Years
5
3 years / 120 000 km
Warranty Kilometers
5
3 years / 120 000 km
Roadside Assistance
5 Years
-
Anti-Corrosion Warranty
5 Years
-
Basic Warranty
5
3 years / 120 000 km
Roadside Assistance
5 Years
-
Warranty
5
3 years / 120 000 km
Warranty Roadside Assistance
5 Years
-
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
CO2 Emissions
123 g/km
121 g/km
Start Stop System
No
-
Hybrid System Type
-
-
Fuel Octane Requirement
Unleaded 95
Petrol
Particulate Filter
-
-
Euro Emission Standard
Euro 6
-
Idle CO2 Output
123
121
Fuel Evaporation Control
Yes
-
CO2 Emissions G Km
123
121
Spec
Grand i10
Polo
Ownership Role
Fluid
South Africa market model
Price Source
South Africa variant price CSV; verify against latest OEM price list
South Africa variant price CSV; verify against latest OEM price list
Price Zar
242900 ZAR
585800 ZAR
Pricing Role
Current listed price
Active local lineup
Starting Price
242900
585800
Starting Price Zar
242900
585800
Overall Verdict Score
Decision-grade view of the winner, score gap and category strengths.
Weighted / 100
Verdict readout
Grand i10 leads by 3 points
Both Grand i10 and Polo are extremely closely matched, making the final choice dependent on buyer preference.
Performance
Polo +35
Efficiency
Polo +5
Safety
Grand i10 +31
Practicality
Level
Ownership
Grand i10 +39
Very close match. Final decision depends on buyer preference.
Why this scoreView full breakdown
Overall Winner
Grand i10
Performance
27/100
Efficiency
66/100
Safety
76/100
Practicality
55/100
Ownership
65/100
Polo
Performance
62/100
Efficiency
71/100
Safety
45/100
Practicality
55/100
Ownership
26/100
So, Which One Should You Buy?
🏆Hyundai Grand i10
wins with 56 pts
vs 53 pts for Polo
In structured scoring, Grand i10 emerges as the stronger overall package. However, Polo may appeal to buyers prioritising different factors. Ultimately, the right choice depends on your driving priorities in South Africa.
Other Comparisons Worth Checking
See how similar cars go head-to-head — you might find a better fit than you expected.
On our scoring the Grand i10 edges ahead overall. That said, the right choice depends on what you actually use the car for — the breakdown above shows exactly where each one wins and loses.
Efficiency scores: Grand i10 66 vs Polo 71. In the real world, diesel variants of either car will beat the claimed figure on long highways and fall short in Joburg traffic.
Safety scores: Grand i10 76, Polo 45. Check each model page for NCAP ratings and which trim levels include AEB and blind-spot monitoring — those features aren't always standard.
Long-term ownership scores: Grand i10 65, Polo 26. Service intervals, parts availability in SA, and whether a service plan is bundled all factor in — check the individual variant specs for that detail.
Practicality scores: Grand i10 55, Polo 55. This covers boot space, seat flexibility, and day-to-day usability — not just interior dimensions on paper.
Performance scores: Grand i10 27, Polo 62. This looks at real-world pace — 0–100 kph, highway flexibility, and how either car feels when you actually need to overtake on an N-road.
Resale varies with colour, spec, and market timing, but Japanese brands — and Toyota specifically — have a strong track record in SA. Check current used prices for both on AutoTrader to see the real gap right now.
Ground clearance and 4WD availability are what matter most here. Scroll to the spec table above to compare both side by side — if either model offers a 4WD variant, that's the version worth comparing.
Fuel, insurance, and service costs are the big three. Diesel variants of both models typically save R800–R1,500/month in fuel at current SA pump prices. The Grand i10 edges the overall ownership score, but check whether either variant includes a service plan — that changes the monthly maths significantly.
The Grand i10 scores better overall, but neither car is a bad buy here. It comes down to what features matter to you — check the full spec table above to see exactly what you gain and lose at each price point.
In Depth — Breaking It All Down
The comparison between Grand i10 and Polo in South Africa
evaluates performance, efficiency, safety, practicality and long-term ownership value.
Performance: Grand i10 scores 27 vs 62.
Efficiency: Grand i10 scores 66 vs 71.
Safety: Grand i10 scores 76 vs 45.
Practicality: Grand i10 scores 55 vs 55.
Ownership: Grand i10 scores 65 vs 26.
Final structured scoring gives Grand i10
the advantage in this comparison.
Compare
Get Best Price
We'll Contact You
Fill in your details and a dedicated executive will reach out shortly.
✓
We've Got Your Details!
An executive will contact you shortly. Thank you for your interest.